
--
-- Table structure for table `migrations`
--

CREATE TABLE `migrations` (
  `id` int unsigned NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
  `migration` varchar(255) COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `batch` int NOT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`id`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB AUTO_INCREMENT=24 DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci;

--
-- Dumping data for table `migrations`
--

INSERT INTO `migrations` VALUES (2,'0001_01_01_000001_create_cache_table',1),(3,'0001_01_01_000002_create_jobs_table',1),(4,'2024_11_04_055718_create_titles_table',2),(5,'2024_11_04_055727_create_countries_table',2),(6,'2024_11_04_065457_create_fetp_statuses_table',3),(7,'2024_11_04_065505_create_fetp_tiers_table',3),(9,'2024_11_04_070258_create_workshops_table',4),(12,'2024_11_05_140637_create_sub_themes_table',6),(13,'2024_11_05_093523_create_submit_abstracts_table',7),(14,'0001_01_01_000000_create_users_table',1),(16,'2024_11_05_093542_create_confirms_table',8),(17,'2024_11_06_113907_create_permission_tables',8),(18,'2024_11_07_064833_create_notifications_table',9),(19,'2024_12_03_120344_create_deadlines_table',10),(20,'2024_12_14_132119_create_review_criterias_table',11),(21,'2024_12_14_132204_create_reviews_table',12),(23,'2024_12_06_165359_create_abstract_assignments_table',13);

--
-- Table structure for table `model_has_permissions`
--

CREATE TABLE `model_has_permissions` (
  `permission_id` bigint unsigned NOT NULL,
  `model_type` varchar(255) COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `model_id` bigint unsigned NOT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`permission_id`,`model_id`,`model_type`),
  KEY `model_has_permissions_model_id_model_type_index` (`model_id`,`model_type`),
  CONSTRAINT `model_has_permissions_permission_id_foreign` FOREIGN KEY (`permission_id`) REFERENCES `permissions` (`id`) ON DELETE CASCADE
) ENGINE=InnoDB DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci;

--
-- Dumping data for table `model_has_permissions`
--


--
-- Table structure for table `model_has_roles`
--

CREATE TABLE `model_has_roles` (
  `role_id` bigint unsigned NOT NULL,
  `model_type` varchar(255) COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `model_id` bigint unsigned NOT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`role_id`,`model_id`,`model_type`),
  KEY `model_has_roles_model_id_model_type_index` (`model_id`,`model_type`),
  CONSTRAINT `model_has_roles_role_id_foreign` FOREIGN KEY (`role_id`) REFERENCES `roles` (`id`) ON DELETE CASCADE
) ENGINE=InnoDB DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci;

--
-- Dumping data for table `model_has_roles`
--

INSERT INTO `model_has_roles` VALUES (1,'App\\Models\\User',4),(2,'App\\Models\\User',5),(2,'App\\Models\\User',7),(4,'App\\Models\\User',8),(3,'App\\Models\\User',9),(2,'App\\Models\\User',10),(4,'App\\Models\\User',10),(3,'App\\Models\\User',11),(4,'App\\Models\\User',12),(4,'App\\Models\\User',13),(4,'App\\Models\\User',14),(2,'App\\Models\\User',15),(2,'App\\Models\\User',16),(2,'App\\Models\\User',17),(2,'App\\Models\\User',18),(1,'App\\Models\\User',19),(4,'App\\Models\\User',20),(2,'App\\Models\\User',21),(2,'App\\Models\\User',22),(2,'App\\Models\\User',23),(4,'App\\Models\\User',24),(2,'App\\Models\\User',25),(2,'App\\Models\\User',26),(2,'App\\Models\\User',27),(2,'App\\Models\\User',28),(2,'App\\Models\\User',29),(2,'App\\Models\\User',30),(2,'App\\Models\\User',31),(2,'App\\Models\\User',32),(2,'App\\Models\\User',33),(2,'App\\Models\\User',34),(2,'App\\Models\\User',35),(2,'App\\Models\\User',36),(2,'App\\Models\\User',37),(2,'App\\Models\\User',38),(2,'App\\Models\\User',39),(2,'App\\Models\\User',40),(2,'App\\Models\\User',41),(2,'App\\Models\\User',42),(2,'App\\Models\\User',43),(2,'App\\Models\\User',44),(2,'App\\Models\\User',45),(2,'App\\Models\\User',46),(2,'App\\Models\\User',47),(2,'App\\Models\\User',48),(2,'App\\Models\\User',49),(2,'App\\Models\\User',50),(2,'App\\Models\\User',51),(2,'App\\Models\\User',52),(2,'App\\Models\\User',53),(2,'App\\Models\\User',54),(2,'App\\Models\\User',55),(2,'App\\Models\\User',56),(2,'App\\Models\\User',57),(2,'App\\Models\\User',58),(2,'App\\Models\\User',59),(2,'App\\Models\\User',60),(2,'App\\Models\\User',61),(2,'App\\Models\\User',62),(2,'App\\Models\\User',63),(2,'App\\Models\\User',64),(2,'App\\Models\\User',65),(4,'App\\Models\\User',66),(2,'App\\Models\\User',67),(2,'App\\Models\\User',68),(2,'App\\Models\\User',69),(2,'App\\Models\\User',70),(2,'App\\Models\\User',71),(2,'App\\Models\\User',72),(2,'App\\Models\\User',73),(2,'App\\Models\\User',74),(2,'App\\Models\\User',75),(2,'App\\Models\\User',76),(2,'App\\Models\\User',77),(2,'App\\Models\\User',78),(2,'App\\Models\\User',79),(2,'App\\Models\\User',80),(2,'App\\Models\\User',81),(2,'App\\Models\\User',82),(2,'App\\Models\\User',83),(2,'App\\Models\\User',84),(2,'App\\Models\\User',85),(2,'App\\Models\\User',86),(2,'App\\Models\\User',87),(2,'App\\Models\\User',88),(2,'App\\Models\\User',89),(2,'App\\Models\\User',90),(2,'App\\Models\\User',91),(2,'App\\Models\\User',92),(2,'App\\Models\\User',93),(2,'App\\Models\\User',94),(2,'App\\Models\\User',95),(2,'App\\Models\\User',96),(2,'App\\Models\\User',97),(2,'App\\Models\\User',98),(2,'App\\Models\\User',99),(2,'App\\Models\\User',100),(4,'App\\Models\\User',101),(2,'App\\Models\\User',102),(2,'App\\Models\\User',103),(2,'App\\Models\\User',104),(2,'App\\Models\\User',105),(2,'App\\Models\\User',106),(2,'App\\Models\\User',107),(2,'App\\Models\\User',108),(2,'App\\Models\\User',109),(2,'App\\Models\\User',110),(2,'App\\Models\\User',111),(2,'App\\Models\\User',112),(2,'App\\Models\\User',113),(2,'App\\Models\\User',114),(2,'App\\Models\\User',115),(2,'App\\Models\\User',116),(2,'App\\Models\\User',117),(2,'App\\Models\\User',118),(2,'App\\Models\\User',119),(2,'App\\Models\\User',120),(4,'App\\Models\\User',121),(4,'App\\Models\\User',122),(4,'App\\Models\\User',123),(4,'App\\Models\\User',126),(4,'App\\Models\\User',131),(4,'App\\Models\\User',132),(4,'App\\Models\\User',134),(4,'App\\Models\\User',135),(4,'App\\Models\\User',136),(4,'App\\Models\\User',137),(4,'App\\Models\\User',138),(4,'App\\Models\\User',139),(4,'App\\Models\\User',140),(4,'App\\Models\\User',141),(4,'App\\Models\\User',142),(4,'App\\Models\\User',143),(4,'App\\Models\\User',144),(4,'App\\Models\\User',145),(4,'App\\Models\\User',147),(4,'App\\Models\\User',148),(4,'App\\Models\\User',149),(4,'App\\Models\\User',150),(4,'App\\Models\\User',151),(4,'App\\Models\\User',152),(4,'App\\Models\\User',153),(4,'App\\Models\\User',154),(4,'App\\Models\\User',155),(4,'App\\Models\\User',156),(4,'App\\Models\\User',157),(4,'App\\Models\\User',158),(4,'App\\Models\\User',159),(4,'App\\Models\\User',160),(4,'App\\Models\\User',161),(4,'App\\Models\\User',162),(4,'App\\Models\\User',163),(4,'App\\Models\\User',164),(4,'App\\Models\\User',165),(4,'App\\Models\\User',166),(4,'App\\Models\\User',167),(4,'App\\Models\\User',168),(4,'App\\Models\\User',169),(4,'App\\Models\\User',170),(4,'App\\Models\\User',171),(4,'App\\Models\\User',172),(4,'App\\Models\\User',173),(4,'App\\Models\\User',174),(4,'App\\Models\\User',175),(2,'App\\Models\\User',176);

--
-- Table structure for table `notifications`
--

CREATE TABLE `notifications` (
  `id` char(36) COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `type` varchar(255) COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `notifiable_type` varchar(255) COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `notifiable_id` bigint unsigned NOT NULL,
  `data` text COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `read_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  `created_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  `updated_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`id`),
  KEY `notifications_notifiable_type_notifiable_id_index` (`notifiable_type`,`notifiable_id`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci;

--
-- Dumping data for table `notifications`
--

INSERT INTO `notifications` VALUES ('03a4fa88-3fe6-4491-b478-df472d7cd052','Filament\\Notifications\\DatabaseNotification','App\\Models\\User',4,'{\"actions\":[{\"name\":\"markAsUnread\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as unread\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":false,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":true,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"},{\"name\":\"markAsRead\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as read\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":true,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":false,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"}],\"body\":\"Please note: An Abstract with the following details has been created: \\n                **Abstract Name:** <p>Health care workers knowledge, perceptions and attitudes towards Coronavirus Disease 19 prevention and control during the pandemic in Tigray, Ethiopia<\\/p>\\n                **Track:** Maternal, Reproductive, and Child Health\\n                **Author:** Munir Makumbi\\n                **Date Submitted:** 2024-11-07 07:40:00\",\"color\":null,\"duration\":\"persistent\",\"icon\":\"heroicon-o-clipboard-document-check\",\"iconColor\":\"success\",\"status\":\"success\",\"title\":\"An Abstract titled \'<p>Health care workers knowledge, perceptions and attitudes towards Coronavirus Disease 19 prevention and control during the pandemic in Tigray, Ethiopia<\\/p>\' has been Edited\",\"view\":\"filament-notifications::notification\",\"viewData\":[],\"format\":\"filament\"}',NULL,'2024-11-07 04:56:54','2024-11-07 04:56:54'),('20f0bbab-a29f-4953-b8d0-6390fa2c27d0','Filament\\Notifications\\DatabaseNotification','App\\Models\\User',4,'{\"actions\":[{\"name\":\"markAsUnread\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as unread\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":false,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":true,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"},{\"name\":\"markAsRead\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as read\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":true,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":false,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"}],\"body\":\"Please note: A country with the following details has been Edited: \\n                    Country Name:\'Oman.\', Country Code:\'OMN\', Dialing Code:\'+968\'.\",\"color\":null,\"duration\":\"persistent\",\"icon\":\"heroicon-o-clipboard-document-check\",\"iconColor\":\"success\",\"status\":\"success\",\"title\":\"Counntry \'Oman.\' has been created\",\"view\":\"filament-notifications::notification\",\"viewData\":[],\"format\":\"filament\"}',NULL,'2024-11-07 04:24:24','2024-11-07 04:24:24'),('476dc31b-6ab9-43c3-9d74-9419f064d1db','Filament\\Notifications\\DatabaseNotification','App\\Models\\User',19,'{\"actions\":[{\"name\":\"markAsUnread\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as unread\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":false,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":true,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"},{\"name\":\"markAsRead\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as read\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":true,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":false,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"}],\"body\":\"Please note: An Abstract with the following details has been created: \\n                    Name:<p>Communications in EFETP<\\/p>, Track:Communication & Technological Innovations for Public Health, Auther:Adamu Addissie on 2024-11-16 08:11:37.\",\"color\":null,\"duration\":\"persistent\",\"icon\":\"heroicon-o-clipboard-document-check\",\"iconColor\":\"success\",\"status\":\"success\",\"title\":\"An Abstract titled \'<p>Communications in EFETP<\\/p>\' has been created\",\"view\":\"filament-notifications::notification\",\"viewData\":[],\"format\":\"filament\"}',NULL,'2024-11-18 13:31:45','2024-11-18 13:31:45'),('4a87a7f2-d2e1-4924-93b7-3f36d7fdbf96','Filament\\Notifications\\DatabaseNotification','App\\Models\\User',19,'{\"actions\":[{\"name\":\"markAsUnread\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as unread\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":false,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":true,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"},{\"name\":\"markAsRead\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as read\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":true,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":false,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"}],\"body\":\"Please note: An Abstract with the following details has been created: \\n                    Name:<p>NCDs Surveillance in Ethiopia&nbsp;<\\/p>, Track:Non-communicable Diseases (NCDs), Injuries & Mental Health, Auther:Adamu Addissie on 2024-11-16 08:29:34.\",\"color\":null,\"duration\":\"persistent\",\"icon\":\"heroicon-o-clipboard-document-check\",\"iconColor\":\"success\",\"status\":\"success\",\"title\":\"An Abstract titled \'<p>NCDs Surveillance in Ethiopia&nbsp;<\\/p>\' has been created\",\"view\":\"filament-notifications::notification\",\"viewData\":[],\"format\":\"filament\"}',NULL,'2024-11-18 13:31:45','2024-11-18 13:31:45'),('4cb41108-ef05-4ec5-af8a-f79717307a08','Filament\\Notifications\\DatabaseNotification','App\\Models\\User',4,'{\"actions\":[{\"name\":\"markAsUnread\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as unread\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":false,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":true,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"},{\"name\":\"markAsRead\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as read\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":true,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":false,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"}],\"body\":\"Please note: A country with the following details has been Edited: \\n                    Country Name:\'Oman.\', Country Code:\'OMN\', Dialing Code:\'+999\'.\",\"color\":null,\"duration\":\"persistent\",\"icon\":\"heroicon-o-clipboard-document-check\",\"iconColor\":\"success\",\"status\":\"success\",\"title\":\"Counntry \'Oman.\' has been created\",\"view\":\"filament-notifications::notification\",\"viewData\":[],\"format\":\"filament\"}',NULL,'2024-11-07 04:23:51','2024-11-07 04:23:51'),('54363c69-70af-4c3c-83ef-88e1a17f4ffd','Filament\\Notifications\\DatabaseNotification','App\\Models\\User',4,'{\"actions\":[{\"name\":\"markAsUnread\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as unread\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":false,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":true,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"},{\"name\":\"markAsRead\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as read\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":true,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":false,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"}],\"body\":\"Please note: An Abstract with the following details has been created: \\n                    Name:<p>Health care workers knowledge, perceptions and attitudes towards Coronavirus Disease 19 prevention and control during the pandemic in Tigray, Ethiopia<\\/p>, Track:Maternal, Reproductive, and Child Health, Auther:Munir Makumbi on 2024-11-07 07:40:00.\",\"color\":null,\"duration\":\"persistent\",\"icon\":\"heroicon-o-clipboard-document-check\",\"iconColor\":\"success\",\"status\":\"success\",\"title\":\"An Abstract titled \'<p>Health care workers knowledge, perceptions and attitudes towards Coronavirus Disease 19 prevention and control during the pandemic in Tigray, Ethiopia<\\/p>\' has been Edited\",\"view\":\"filament-notifications::notification\",\"viewData\":[],\"format\":\"filament\"}',NULL,'2024-11-07 04:50:15','2024-11-07 04:50:15'),('54ef2a74-7ca4-4a97-b0c4-30a0a78fa9ff','Filament\\Notifications\\DatabaseNotification','App\\Models\\User',4,'{\"actions\":[{\"name\":\"markAsUnread\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as unread\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":false,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":true,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"},{\"name\":\"markAsRead\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as read\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":true,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":false,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"}],\"body\":\"Please note: An Abstract with the following details has been created: \\n                    Name:\'<p>y<\\/p>\', Track:\'One Health and Climate Change\', Auther:\'Munir\' \'Makumbi\' on \'\'.\",\"color\":null,\"duration\":\"persistent\",\"icon\":\"heroicon-o-clipboard-document-check\",\"iconColor\":\"success\",\"status\":\"success\",\"title\":\"An Abstract titled \'<p>y<\\/p>\' has been created\",\"view\":\"filament-notifications::notification\",\"viewData\":[],\"format\":\"filament\"}',NULL,'2024-11-07 04:45:50','2024-11-07 04:45:50'),('558ac631-b351-4e24-a71a-dfafd2c2dd62','Filament\\Notifications\\DatabaseNotification','App\\Models\\User',11,'{\"actions\":[{\"name\":\"markAsUnread\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as unread\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":false,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":true,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"},{\"name\":\"markAsRead\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as read\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":true,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":false,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"}],\"body\":\"Please note: An Abstract with the following details has been created: \\n                    Name:<p>Communications in EFETP<\\/p>, Track:Communication & Technological Innovations for Public Health, Auther:Adamu Addissie on 2024-11-16 08:11:37.\",\"color\":null,\"duration\":\"persistent\",\"icon\":\"heroicon-o-clipboard-document-check\",\"iconColor\":\"success\",\"status\":\"success\",\"title\":\"An Abstract titled \'<p>Communications in EFETP<\\/p>\' has been created\",\"view\":\"filament-notifications::notification\",\"viewData\":[],\"format\":\"filament\"}',NULL,'2024-11-18 13:31:45','2024-11-18 13:31:45'),('aaa8c571-d561-4d53-a930-00a1d9a8d581','Filament\\Notifications\\DatabaseNotification','App\\Models\\User',4,'{\"actions\":[{\"name\":\"markAsUnread\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as unread\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":false,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":true,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"},{\"name\":\"markAsRead\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as read\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":true,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":false,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"}],\"body\":\"Please note: A country with the following details has been created: \\n                    Country Name:\'Oman\', Country Code:\'OMN\', Dialing Code:\'+968\'.\",\"color\":null,\"duration\":\"persistent\",\"icon\":\"heroicon-o-clipboard-document-check\",\"iconColor\":\"success\",\"status\":\"success\",\"title\":\"Counntry \'Oman\' has been created\",\"view\":\"filament-notifications::notification\",\"viewData\":[],\"format\":\"filament\"}',NULL,'2024-11-07 04:17:12','2024-11-07 04:17:12'),('b4f9cfdd-11eb-40b7-a7e2-bc83a791a787','Filament\\Notifications\\DatabaseNotification','App\\Models\\User',11,'{\"actions\":[{\"name\":\"markAsUnread\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as unread\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":false,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":true,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"},{\"name\":\"markAsRead\",\"color\":null,\"event\":null,\"eventData\":[],\"dispatchDirection\":false,\"dispatchToComponent\":null,\"extraAttributes\":[],\"icon\":null,\"iconPosition\":\"before\",\"iconSize\":null,\"isOutlined\":false,\"isDisabled\":false,\"label\":\"Mark as read\",\"shouldClose\":false,\"shouldMarkAsRead\":true,\"shouldMarkAsUnread\":false,\"shouldOpenUrlInNewTab\":false,\"size\":\"sm\",\"tooltip\":null,\"url\":null,\"view\":\"filament-actions::button-action\"}],\"body\":\"Please note: An Abstract with the following details has been created: \\n                    Name:<p>NCDs Surveillance in Ethiopia&nbsp;<\\/p>, Track:Non-communicable Diseases (NCDs), Injuries & Mental Health, Auther:Adamu Addissie on 2024-11-16 08:29:34.\",\"color\":null,\"duration\":\"persistent\",\"icon\":\"heroicon-o-clipboard-document-check\",\"iconColor\":\"success\",\"status\":\"success\",\"title\":\"An Abstract titled \'<p>NCDs Surveillance in Ethiopia&nbsp;<\\/p>\' has been created\",\"view\":\"filament-notifications::notification\",\"viewData\":[],\"format\":\"filament\"}',NULL,'2024-11-18 13:31:45','2024-11-18 13:31:45');

--
-- Table structure for table `permissions`
--

CREATE TABLE `permissions` (
  `id` bigint unsigned NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
  `name` varchar(255) COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `guard_name` varchar(255) COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `created_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  `updated_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`id`),
  UNIQUE KEY `permissions_name_guard_name_unique` (`name`,`guard_name`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB AUTO_INCREMENT=149 DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci;

--
-- Dumping data for table `permissions`
--

INSERT INTO `permissions` VALUES (1,'view_country','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(2,'view_any_country','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(3,'create_country','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(4,'update_country','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(5,'restore_country','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(6,'restore_any_country','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(7,'replicate_country','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(8,'reorder_country','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(9,'delete_country','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(10,'delete_any_country','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(11,'force_delete_country','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(12,'force_delete_any_country','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(13,'view_fetp::status','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(14,'view_any_fetp::status','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(15,'create_fetp::status','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(16,'update_fetp::status','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(17,'restore_fetp::status','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(18,'restore_any_fetp::status','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(19,'replicate_fetp::status','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(20,'reorder_fetp::status','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(21,'delete_fetp::status','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(22,'delete_any_fetp::status','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(23,'force_delete_fetp::status','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(24,'force_delete_any_fetp::status','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(25,'view_fetp::tier','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(26,'view_any_fetp::tier','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(27,'create_fetp::tier','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(28,'update_fetp::tier','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(29,'restore_fetp::tier','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(30,'restore_any_fetp::tier','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(31,'replicate_fetp::tier','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(32,'reorder_fetp::tier','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(33,'delete_fetp::tier','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(34,'delete_any_fetp::tier','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(35,'force_delete_fetp::tier','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(36,'force_delete_any_fetp::tier','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(37,'view_role','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(38,'view_any_role','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(39,'create_role','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(40,'update_role','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(41,'delete_role','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(42,'delete_any_role','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(43,'view_sub::theme','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(44,'view_any_sub::theme','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(45,'create_sub::theme','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(46,'update_sub::theme','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(47,'restore_sub::theme','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(48,'restore_any_sub::theme','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(49,'replicate_sub::theme','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(50,'reorder_sub::theme','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(51,'delete_sub::theme','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(52,'delete_any_sub::theme','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(53,'force_delete_sub::theme','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(54,'force_delete_any_sub::theme','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(55,'view_submit::abstract','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(56,'view_any_submit::abstract','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(57,'create_submit::abstract','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(58,'update_submit::abstract','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(59,'restore_submit::abstract','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(60,'restore_any_submit::abstract','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(61,'replicate_submit::abstract','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(62,'reorder_submit::abstract','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(63,'delete_submit::abstract','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(64,'delete_any_submit::abstract','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(65,'force_delete_submit::abstract','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(66,'force_delete_any_submit::abstract','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(67,'view_title','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(68,'view_any_title','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(69,'create_title','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(70,'update_title','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(71,'restore_title','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(72,'restore_any_title','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(73,'replicate_title','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(74,'reorder_title','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(75,'delete_title','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(76,'delete_any_title','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(77,'force_delete_title','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(78,'force_delete_any_title','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(79,'view_workshop','web','2024-11-06 08:41:48','2024-11-06 08:41:48'),(80,'view_any_workshop','web','2024-11-06 08:41:48','2024-11-06 08:41:48'),(81,'create_workshop','web','2024-11-06 08:41:48','2024-11-06 08:41:48'),(82,'update_workshop','web','2024-11-06 08:41:48','2024-11-06 08:41:48'),(83,'restore_workshop','web','2024-11-06 08:41:48','2024-11-06 08:41:48'),(84,'restore_any_workshop','web','2024-11-06 08:41:48','2024-11-06 08:41:48'),(85,'replicate_workshop','web','2024-11-06 08:41:48','2024-11-06 08:41:48'),(86,'reorder_workshop','web','2024-11-06 08:41:48','2024-11-06 08:41:48'),(87,'delete_workshop','web','2024-11-06 08:41:48','2024-11-06 08:41:48'),(88,'delete_any_workshop','web','2024-11-06 08:41:48','2024-11-06 08:41:48'),(89,'force_delete_workshop','web','2024-11-06 08:41:48','2024-11-06 08:41:48'),(90,'force_delete_any_workshop','web','2024-11-06 08:41:48','2024-11-06 08:41:48'),(91,'page_MyProfilePage','web','2024-11-06 08:41:48','2024-11-06 08:41:48'),(92,'view_user','web','2024-11-06 08:53:43','2024-11-06 08:53:43'),(93,'view_any_user','web','2024-11-06 08:53:43','2024-11-06 08:53:43'),(94,'create_user','web','2024-11-06 08:53:43','2024-11-06 08:53:43'),(95,'update_user','web','2024-11-06 08:53:43','2024-11-06 08:53:43'),(96,'restore_user','web','2024-11-06 08:53:43','2024-11-06 08:53:43'),(97,'restore_any_user','web','2024-11-06 08:53:43','2024-11-06 08:53:43'),(98,'replicate_user','web','2024-11-06 08:53:43','2024-11-06 08:53:43'),(99,'reorder_user','web','2024-11-06 08:53:43','2024-11-06 08:53:43'),(100,'delete_user','web','2024-11-06 08:53:43','2024-11-06 08:53:43'),(101,'delete_any_user','web','2024-11-06 08:53:43','2024-11-06 08:53:43'),(102,'force_delete_user','web','2024-11-06 08:53:43','2024-11-06 08:53:43'),(103,'force_delete_any_user','web','2024-11-06 08:53:43','2024-11-06 08:53:43'),(104,'view_notification','web','2024-11-07 05:21:39','2024-11-07 05:21:39'),(105,'view_any_notification','web','2024-11-07 05:21:39','2024-11-07 05:21:39'),(106,'widget_StatsOverview','web','2024-11-18 13:29:18','2024-11-18 13:29:18'),(107,'widget_AbstractsButtonWidget','web','2024-11-18 13:29:18','2024-11-18 13:29:18'),(108,'widget_AccordionWidget','web','2024-11-18 13:29:18','2024-11-18 13:29:18'),(109,'view_review::criteria','web','2024-12-22 10:58:50','2024-12-22 10:58:50'),(110,'view_any_review::criteria','web','2024-12-22 10:58:50','2024-12-22 10:58:50'),(111,'create_review::criteria','web','2024-12-22 10:58:50','2024-12-22 10:58:50'),(112,'update_review::criteria','web','2024-12-22 10:58:50','2024-12-22 10:58:50'),(113,'restore_review::criteria','web','2024-12-22 10:58:50','2024-12-22 10:58:50'),(114,'restore_any_review::criteria','web','2024-12-22 10:58:50','2024-12-22 10:58:50'),(115,'replicate_review::criteria','web','2024-12-22 10:58:50','2024-12-22 10:58:50'),(116,'reorder_review::criteria','web','2024-12-22 10:58:50','2024-12-22 10:58:50'),(117,'delete_review::criteria','web','2024-12-22 10:58:50','2024-12-22 10:58:50'),(118,'delete_any_review::criteria','web','2024-12-22 10:58:50','2024-12-22 10:58:50'),(119,'force_delete_review::criteria','web','2024-12-22 10:58:50','2024-12-22 10:58:50'),(120,'force_delete_any_review::criteria','web','2024-12-22 10:58:50','2024-12-22 10:58:50'),(121,'view_abstract::assignment','web','2024-12-22 10:59:19','2024-12-22 10:59:19'),(122,'view_any_abstract::assignment','web','2024-12-22 10:59:19','2024-12-22 10:59:19'),(123,'create_abstract::assignment','web','2024-12-22 10:59:19','2024-12-22 10:59:19'),(124,'update_abstract::assignment','web','2024-12-22 10:59:19','2024-12-22 10:59:19'),(125,'restore_abstract::assignment','web','2024-12-22 10:59:19','2024-12-22 10:59:19'),(126,'restore_any_abstract::assignment','web','2024-12-22 10:59:19','2024-12-22 10:59:19'),(127,'replicate_abstract::assignment','web','2024-12-22 10:59:19','2024-12-22 10:59:19'),(128,'reorder_abstract::assignment','web','2024-12-22 10:59:19','2024-12-22 10:59:19'),(129,'delete_abstract::assignment','web','2024-12-22 10:59:19','2024-12-22 10:59:19'),(130,'delete_any_abstract::assignment','web','2024-12-22 10:59:19','2024-12-22 10:59:19'),(131,'force_delete_abstract::assignment','web','2024-12-22 10:59:19','2024-12-22 10:59:19'),(132,'force_delete_any_abstract::assignment','web','2024-12-22 10:59:19','2024-12-22 10:59:19'),(133,'view_deadline','web','2024-12-22 10:59:28','2024-12-22 10:59:28'),(134,'view_any_deadline','web','2024-12-22 10:59:28','2024-12-22 10:59:28'),(135,'create_deadline','web','2024-12-22 10:59:28','2024-12-22 10:59:28'),(136,'update_deadline','web','2024-12-22 10:59:28','2024-12-22 10:59:28'),(137,'restore_deadline','web','2024-12-22 10:59:28','2024-12-22 10:59:28'),(138,'restore_any_deadline','web','2024-12-22 10:59:28','2024-12-22 10:59:28'),(139,'replicate_deadline','web','2024-12-22 10:59:28','2024-12-22 10:59:28'),(140,'reorder_deadline','web','2024-12-22 10:59:28','2024-12-22 10:59:28'),(141,'delete_deadline','web','2024-12-22 10:59:28','2024-12-22 10:59:28'),(142,'delete_any_deadline','web','2024-12-22 10:59:28','2024-12-22 10:59:28'),(143,'force_delete_deadline','web','2024-12-22 10:59:28','2024-12-22 10:59:28'),(144,'force_delete_any_deadline','web','2024-12-22 10:59:28','2024-12-22 10:59:28'),(145,'view_review','web','2024-12-22 11:01:20','2024-12-22 11:01:20'),(146,'view_any_review','web','2024-12-22 11:01:20','2024-12-22 11:01:20'),(147,'create_review','web','2024-12-22 11:01:20','2024-12-22 11:01:20'),(148,'update_review','web','2024-12-22 11:01:20','2024-12-22 11:01:20');

--
-- Table structure for table `review_criterias`
--

CREATE TABLE `review_criterias` (
  `id` bigint unsigned NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
  `name` varchar(255) COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `description` text COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `max_score` int NOT NULL,
  `is_active` tinyint(1) NOT NULL DEFAULT '1',
  `created_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  `updated_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`id`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci;

--
-- Dumping data for table `review_criterias`
--


--
-- Table structure for table `reviews`
--

CREATE TABLE `reviews` (
  `id` bigint unsigned NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
  `abstract_id` bigint unsigned NOT NULL,
  `reviewer_id` bigint unsigned NOT NULL,
  `status` enum('draft','submitted') CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL DEFAULT 'draft',
  `submitted_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  `created_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  `updated_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  `originality_score` int DEFAULT NULL,
  `originality_comment` text CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci,
  `clinical_relevance_score` int DEFAULT NULL,
  `clinical_relevance_comment` text CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci,
  `methodology_score` int DEFAULT NULL,
  `methodology_comment` text CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci,
  `presentation_score` int DEFAULT NULL,
  `presentation_comment` text CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci,
  `feasibility_score` int DEFAULT NULL,
  `feasibility_comment` text CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci,
  `overall_clarity_score` int DEFAULT NULL,
  `overall_clarity_comment` text CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci,
  PRIMARY KEY (`id`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB AUTO_INCREMENT=288 DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci;

--
-- Dumping data for table `reviews`
--

INSERT INTO `reviews` VALUES (2,19,8,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-28 11:55:05','2024-12-28 11:55:05',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,NULL),(5,20,150,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-30 09:44:28','2024-12-30 09:44:28',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(6,38,150,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-30 09:46:28','2024-12-30 09:46:28',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',2,NULL),(7,54,150,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-30 09:47:44','2024-12-30 09:47:44',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(8,75,150,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-30 09:48:47','2024-12-30 09:48:47',2,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',2,'N/A',4,'N/A',2,NULL),(9,94,150,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-30 09:49:42','2024-12-30 09:49:42',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(10,22,149,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-30 10:23:51','2024-12-30 10:23:51',4,'Objectives for addressing the problem not sufficiently described ',3,'No case definitions, statistical measures inadequately described ',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(11,14,123,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-30 17:21:05','2024-12-30 17:21:05',2,'The Background should cover the importance of the disease and why surveillance for it matters in Ethiopia. It is not necessary to give a textbook definition of surveillance, but instead the author should think about WHY this particular system needs to be evaluated here and now. What is it about measles in Ethiopia that makes it important to have a surveillance system? Why was the system developed? What concerns are there about the data quality or use? Why Chena?',2,'Not adequately described. What characteristics were evaluated? How were data collected? Who was interviewed or what records were used?',2,'While a few details about the system are presented, it\'s not clear if they address the objectives. Does the system meet its objectives? It\'s not possible to tell. There needs to be a more close mapping between the Methods and the Results.',0,'The conclusion should be an interpretation of the meaning of the results as they apply to the objective, not additional results. Ideally, the conclusion would tell us whether or not the surveillance system meets its objectives, based on the results presented in the abstract.',1,'This could have been a useful study but the abstract is not making it possible to tell.',1,NULL),(12,30,123,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-30 17:35:26','2024-12-30 17:35:26',3,'It would have been nice to see information in the background about Strep pyogenes. The reader may know nothing about it. Even though the investigators did not know what was causing the outbreak in the beginning, it\'s still ok to provide info about the pathogen and where it\'s found, who it affects. There is no description of the lesions at all that helps the reader understand how the investigators started to make guesses about the pathogen.',4,'Very nice methods. I would have liked to see information about what the swabs were tested for and where they were tested.',3,'It is not clear how they knew that S. pyogenes (please check your spelling!) was the causative agent. Was 1/11 samples positive? 11/11? Some more information on patient symptoms is needed. In addition, it is not clear that cases were different ages than the controls. Since it was unmatched, I assume that controls were selected randomly. As age is not shown as a risk factor, the conclusion that it disproportionately affected young people is not substantiated.',2,'See comments above. However, I would also like the authors to answer: why did this outbreak happen here and now? What changed that made this outbreak happen during this time period and in this place? Presumably people have been living under the same conditions for many years. So why did this happen?',4,'N/A',5,NULL),(13,51,123,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-30 17:43:25','2024-12-30 17:43:25',4,'The background is fairly good but it should be noted that surveillance is not an intervention. It is a tool to assess trends and disease burden.',5,'N/A',3,'It is clear from the Results that the cases are increasing. However, the reader doesn\'t know the geography of this area. Is Bahr Zur district one of two districts? One of ten? If Bahr Zur district has 25% of the population, then we would expect them to have 25% of the malaria cases. This needs to be clear.  It also would have been nice to see the proportion of cases <5 years for each year. In my experience, 14% being <5 years is very low! Usually most of the cases are <5 years. ',3,'What does \'it occurs in the form of outbreak\' mean? How is this defined here? I think this is not a good use of the words in the abstract. ',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(14,65,123,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-30 17:59:07','2024-12-30 17:59:07',5,NULL,4,'Where and when was this study carried out? Where were women enrolled?',4,'It was not clear which direction the \'husband education\' and \'maternal decision-making autonomy\' was associated with stunting at birth.',1,'The conclusions are a repetition of results. The purpose of the Conclusion section is to interpret the results, not repeat them. What do the results mean, taken together? Why are they important and what recommendations should be made?',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(15,84,123,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-30 18:02:11','2024-12-30 18:02:11',5,'Very nice background.',5,'Well done.',4,'I would have liked to see some demographic information about cases.',3,'The conclusions just repeat the results. What should be taken from this? Is this new information on chronic kidney disease? The concluding sentence is not clear.',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(16,103,123,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-30 18:05:02','2024-12-30 18:05:02',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'What does \'not knowledgeable mothers\' mean here? This could be explained in the Methods.',4,'The conclusions start by repeating the results. This is not necessary. ',4,'N/A',5,NULL),(17,24,153,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-30 19:04:55','2024-12-30 19:04:55',3,'The study issue is among the priority health problems in the Region. However, the title and background and the rationale didn\'t explicitly describe the reason for comparison of adherence among public and private health facilities, which is the main focus of the study.\nThe objectives are not also indicated in the title.',3,'Most of the issues in the methods sections are touched. But, the way how the sample size is calculated, the study units in each stage of sampling are selected, the outcome variable (adherence) is measured are not clearly described.',4,'It is relatively good.\nStill it needs recommended method of writing proportions and AORs with their 95%CIs: estimate (95%CI: lower bound - upper bound).\nIt is also better to indicate the direction of association and keep the consistency of decimals.',2,'The conclusion is not directly based on the results.\nHow much was the standard of adherence to the national malarial case management guideline is not indicated.\nThe need of comparison is not concluded based on the finding.',2,'The Recommendations are not based on the objective and results of the finding.',3,NULL),(18,18,134,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-30 20:31:55','2024-12-30 20:31:55',3,'N/A',2,'N/A',3,'N/A',1,'N/A',2,'N/A',3,NULL),(19,19,135,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-31 06:08:59','2024-12-31 06:08:59',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(20,19,143,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-31 06:56:40','2024-12-31 06:56:40',3,'N/A',3,'Study population is not stated, control section and definition is not clear, Analysis plan were not clearly mentioned.',3,'N/A',1,'The conclusion is simply the repetition of the result section and there is also conclusion is not supported by the findings.',0,'The study does not add any significance',2,NULL),(21,26,167,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-31 07:50:45','2024-12-31 07:50:45',4,'Everything is well-presented; however, including more background on the specific geographical context would improve the understanding of the study\'s relevance.',3,'The methods section did not explain how the qualitative and quantitative data complemented or were linked to each other. Additionally, it did not specify how the data were analyzed or mention specific statistical methods. Furthermore, the process of data collection was not described.',5,'N/A',4,'Everything is well done; however, the study does not explain how data quality was maintained or how potential biases and confounding variables were addressed, which is important for drawing a more reliable conclusion. Additionally, the conclusion should focus more on the identified factors influencing prevention practices, rather than recommending general prevention mechanisms.',5,'N/A',5,NULL),(22,39,143,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-31 08:45:55','2024-12-31 08:45:55',2,'The problem is not mentioned clearly.',3,'-',3,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,'N/A',3,NULL),(23,25,154,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-31 21:04:58','2024-12-31 21:04:58',2,'The authors were narrated very shallow  to the burden of malaria cases from globe to local in the current situation. The authors were not expressed the aim this study.',1,'The authors were not clearly expressed what did they used study design and also wasn\'t stated study unit definition which is cases or controls . and also this study was not indicated the way of data collected or accessed. not determined the sample size. Authors weren\'t expressed the laboratory result which was labratory supported or not?',2,'The authors weren\'t keep the coherence. they weren\'t mentioned the slide positivity rate(SPR) from their study area. they haven\'t expressed which species were dominant in their study.In addition , the authors title said malaria outbreak investigation and response but at the result part haven\'t put which type response conducted in that study area.',1,'Simply the authors are put findings of the result so it wasn\'t appropriate. not recommended the specific intervention based on the findings.',1,'Author\'s recommended activities are not their result finding it is the general recommendation.',1,NULL),(24,116,154,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-31 21:23:10','2024-12-31 21:23:10',5,'No comments because of they are well expressed way.',5,'N/A',4,'Authors weren\'t expressed in findings with time.',4,'they weren\'t recommended specific intervention based on their found findings in the study area, simply only put further study.',4,'It was better data organized and ideas flow. they presented the findings appropriately but based on their finding not recommended in their study area',5,NULL),(25,85,154,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-31 21:38:20','2024-12-31 21:38:20',3,'Not narrated the burden of malaria cases in nowadays from globe to local area.',4,'N/A',3,'Not expressed where more affected place or district or kebeles in the study period, age group, slide positivity rate. Not stated the contribution of malaria cases from total outpatient cases',3,'The recommendations tasks aren\'t fit the objective set and not specific intervention in the study area',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(26,30,172,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-31 21:42:57','2024-12-31 21:42:57',3,'The authors did not clearly describe the objective of the study ',4,'the method part has some basic components like study design, sample size, data collection methods and analysis techniques. But it lacks population and sampling procedure  ',5,'it is written well except it lacks logical flow of ideas. it was best to start with descriptive part. ',4,'The result in this abstract does not contain adequate background information for such conclusion.  ',4,'This study aimed to investigate the outbreak of Streptococcus pyogenes skin infection in South Gondar Zone that affected  more than 914 people within 1 month. ',4,NULL),(27,49,172,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-31 22:02:59','2024-12-31 22:02:59',5,'it is well written and clearly state the objective. ',4,'the method part is very clear and contain most of the necessary information. however, the quantitative part was not describe adequately. ',5,'Similarly, it contains pertinent findings related with the objective of the study.  ',5,'The conclusion addressed objectives. ',5,'the study bring one of the key public health problem of the country ',5,NULL),(28,66,172,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-31 22:13:27','2024-12-31 22:13:27',4,'The author explicitly state the study objective. but it lacks the gap of the study. ',3,'the method section was not clear. it lacks many of the sections of the method. ',4,'it was best to start with the total number of participants. the result part also shallow ',4,'the conclusion part was just repetition of the result part. the recommendation was not based on the result of the study. it was just general recommendation ',4,'the study bring critical public health problem (magnitude of new HIV infection). but it lacks many critical parts ',4,NULL),(29,86,172,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-31 22:41:52','2024-12-31 22:41:52',4,'The objective of the study well presented as \"to assess health and health related problems among internally displaced persons residing at South Wollo Zone, Amhara region\" but the title is to vague ',3,'The method part was not adequately described. ',4,'the result section has some basic part but it lacks numerical descriptions of the main finding like the leading causes of morbidity and others ',4,'It is just repetition of the result section ',5,'internal displacement is one of the main public health problem of the current situation of the country. the study bring this critical problem ',4,NULL),(30,104,172,'submitted',NULL,'2024-12-31 23:09:29','2024-12-31 23:09:29',5,'well presented objective ',4,'good methods but it is not comprehensive ',5,'Well written, focused and organized ',5,'the conclusion, interpretation and recommendations are based on the findings of the study. ',5,'The study bring the current public health issue ',5,NULL),(31,112,150,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-01 05:20:50','2025-01-01 05:20:50',2,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(32,24,165,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-01 11:07:31','2025-01-01 11:07:31',3,'The authors could strengthen the significance of the study by:\n-Highlighting the impact of suboptimal adherence to malaria guidelines on malaria control.\n-Including specific data or trends on malaria in the Afar \n',4,'It is not clear how the authors selected charts and healthcare providers. Does this mean that both the healthcare provider and the patient charts they managed were selected? Otherwise, how do they combine results from charts with the interview with health care providers?',4,'The authors should report the chi-square test to check if there is a significant difference in adherence to malaria case management guidelines between the public and private facilities.',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(33,19,135,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-01 13:07:31','2025-01-01 13:07:31',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(34,37,135,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-01 13:45:42','2025-01-01 13:45:42',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,NULL),(35,51,135,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-01 14:06:09','2025-01-01 14:06:09',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,NULL),(36,17,23,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-01 16:02:39','2025-01-01 16:02:39',3,'Even if malaria is a core public health problem in the nation, the problem is not described well.',2,'There is no explanation of the sample size and statistical methods used to analyze the data.',2,'There is no well-defined description of epidemiological variables such as person, place, and time. The entire numerical figure is overlooked. ',3,' Since the sampling technique is purposive sampling, the result may be affected by bias, chance, and confounding. ',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(37,43,149,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-01 18:00:09','2025-01-01 18:00:09',3,'The study didn\'t address the public health problem in the specific study area ',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(38,76,149,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-01 18:09:01','2025-01-01 18:09:01',3,'Very broad topic and the health problem or questions inadequately described ',2,'The study design not clear, the mixed method study evidences inadequately described, data collection method not clear, how published articles reviewed and included not clear ',3,'N/A',3,'Seems generic ',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(39,96,149,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-01 18:11:56','2025-01-01 18:11:56',4,'N/A',3,'How life style modification practice measured is not clear ',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(40,114,149,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-01 18:17:20','2025-01-01 18:17:20',3,'The public health problem or questions that the study will address not adequately described ',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(41,16,13,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-02 07:55:24','2025-01-02 07:55:24',3,'Needs some information on how many are affected by the conflict',4,'The study area is not mentioned',4,'Description of study participants (such as socio-demography) not stated',3,'Not based on the findings',5,'The topic is a priority and mostly undermined area',4,NULL),(42,34,13,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-02 08:09:02','2025-01-02 08:09:02',5,'N/A',4,'Other covariates included in the study were not discussed',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(43,53,13,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-02 08:16:11','2025-01-02 08:16:11',3,'Did not acknowledge the existing knowledge regarding factors ',3,'Inclusion criteria not mentioned. Outbreak case definition is different from the standard case definition mentioned on PHEM Guideline',3,'Nothing is mentioned about the  holy water utilization ',3,'Repetition of the result section',5,'N/A',3,NULL),(44,67,13,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-02 08:20:46','2025-01-02 08:20:46',4,'N/A',3,'Criteria for selection not discussed',4,'No description of study participants',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(45,86,13,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-02 08:28:58','2025-01-02 08:28:58',4,'N/A',2,'Number of participants was not described',4,'N/A',2,'Results are included in the conclusion section',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(46,105,13,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-02 08:32:27','2025-01-02 08:32:27',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(47,35,23,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-02 11:12:14','2025-01-02 11:12:14',4,'It is well described.',5,'It has a well-written description of epidemiological and statistical methods, including study design and data analysis. ',4,'The results are well-narrated, giving an explanation of significant relationships with the dependent variable. However, I believe it is preferable to use terms such as biomass fuel and fossil fuel rather than clean fuel and solid fuel.',4,'The conclusion clearly indicates the strategies to reduce childhood morbidity risk.',5,'The public health significance of the study is high since it also includes recommendations.',5,NULL),(48,74,135,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-02 11:48:47','2025-01-02 11:48:47',3,'The abstract information not well addressed the significant of this study.',2,'N/A',3,'The information presented in the result section are not proper to reach to the conclusion. ',3,'The conclusion will provide enough information to take the proper action',2,'The data can\'t able to give enough information to build on existing knowledge. ',3,NULL),(49,56,143,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-02 12:20:10','2025-01-02 12:20:10',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,'N/A',3,NULL),(50,92,135,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-02 12:45:32','2025-01-02 12:45:32',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(51,111,135,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-02 13:14:16','2025-01-02 13:14:16',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(52,37,8,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-03 05:56:19','2025-01-03 05:56:19',4,'N/A',3,'Not sure whether a prevalence study is appropriate for such a seasonal acute infection. We have no information about endemicity of the malaria in the area',4,'N/A',3,'The conclusion doesn\'t match with the objectives. Recommendations on asymptomatic malaria are made without any data on the same. ',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(53,57,8,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-03 06:36:13','2025-01-03 06:36:13',2,'N/A',1,'N/A',1,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,NULL),(54,105,173,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-03 06:54:18','2025-01-03 06:54:18',2,'Even though the authors indicated the objective of the study the gap they claimed is not true as several studies (large scale, and national level) were conducted, and issues related to recurrence is well stablished ',3,'The method is okay but could be more appropriate if authors used survival analysis methods that handles recurrent events as recurrence is not one time event but could be more than single recurrence.',3,'similar with method part.',1,'vague recommendation (there is no strong evidence from this study to recommend distribution of primaquine)',1,'They repeated already know fact',2,NULL),(55,66,167,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-03 06:57:28','2025-01-03 06:57:28',3,'Even though the significance of recent HIV infections is explained, it lacks more information on local HIV prevalence and trends in recent infections in the region. In addition, how the Asante test improves the existing strategies should be added in the background to be more explanatory.',3,'The data collection process, participant selection, sample size, sampling method, key definitions (e.g., newly diagnosed cases), adjustment for potential confounders, and the nature of the data were not specified or described. All data were sourced from REDCap, but further details on inclusion criteria and study design were lacking.',4,'The overall sample size and the methods used to control potential confounders were not specified, limiting the adequacy of the conclusion.',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,NULL),(56,47,165,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-03 07:21:06','2025-01-03 07:21:06',4,'The known impact of IDP in health care could be mentioned to show the rationale of the study. The author does not state the objective(s ) of the study',3,'The author does not provide enough detail on the methods used for data collection and sampling. Additionally, there is an apparent inconsistency; while they claim to have employed qualitative data collection methods, the data presentation techniques described appear to align solely with quantitative approaches.',2,'The author does not provide adequate data for readers to engage with meaningfully, presenting only the total number of internally displaced persons (IDPs) and their gender distribution.',3,'The conclusions are not based on the data presented in the result section. ',4,'The study undoubtedly addresses a significant and timely issue. However, the recommendations provided are not adequately supported by the data. For instance, the author suggests strengthening immunization programs without presenting information on the vaccination status within the studied IDP site.',3,NULL),(57,117,165,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-03 08:12:18','2025-01-03 08:12:18',4,'It would be better if the author contextualized the problem in relation to the study area instead of focusing on global cholera cases.',3,'The chosen study design is inadequate to answer one of the research objectives, identifying risk factors. The sample size, sampling procedures, and method of analysis are not clearly indicated.\n',4,'It lacks details on the source and risk factors for the outbreak. ',3,'The conclusions are not supported by data and appear to reflect personal opinion rather than evidence-based findings',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(58,96,152,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-03 10:54:49','2025-01-03 10:54:49',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',5,NULL),(59,63,165,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-03 13:31:27','2025-01-03 13:31:27',5,'N/A',4,'The sampling procedure is not clear\n-lacks clarity on how the samples were collected for the parasitological examination\n-',4,'-The authors didn\'t present what percentage of the NTDs were soil-transmitted helmithes, Trachoma , and skin-related NTDs\n-The authors consider similar factors for the NTDs mentioned above in the regression analysis. However, factors for soil-transmitted heminths may not work for trachoma and vice versa.',4,'The conclusion is likely attributable to chance, as indicated in a very wide CIs Adjusted odds ratio ( e.g. government employment AOR: 12.5 (95%CI: 1.17, 132.4)) ',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(60,57,152,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-04 07:10:46','2025-01-04 07:10:46',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(61,40,152,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-04 07:20:01','2025-01-04 07:20:01',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(62,77,152,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-04 07:30:16','2025-01-04 07:30:16',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(63,114,152,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-04 07:54:25','2025-01-04 07:54:25',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',5,NULL),(64,22,152,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-04 08:08:29','2025-01-04 08:08:29',3,'The objective was not clearly stated',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,NULL),(65,24,160,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-04 09:45:44','2025-01-04 09:45:44',1,'No attention is given on the knowledge gap the study is going to add\nThe research gap is not clear\nRational of the study is missed',3,'superficial, does not tell how each variable had been measured\nMeasure of strength of association is not described in the method section\nData collection methods are not clearly described\nBut element of methodological review missed\n',3,'There is room for improving interpretation of data due to the result interpretation lacks comparison group\nComputing odds ratio above selected variables are not scientifically sound rather than computing proportion i.e better to compute chi-square test considering above variables ',4,'N/A',2,'Research gap is not clear\nlacks adequate detail in the methods section',3,NULL),(66,44,160,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-04 10:24:44','2025-01-04 10:24:44',3,'But the knowledge gap that led to the study is not described at all \nstudy setting gap is not clear\nRational of the study is not clear',2,'Study design is not clear\nDescriptive analysis for continuous and categorical variables are not clearly described\nElement of methodological review missed is missed like case definition is not clear\nMeasure of the strength of association between variable is not clear\nMethods: superficial, does not tell how each variable had been measured and classified\n\n',4,'There is room for improving interpretation of data by including comparison groups\nThe result variable category is not clear',3,'There is room for improving synthesis of data based on big pictures\nStrong justification of the study is not clear\n\n',3,'Strong justification and public health importance of the study are not described at all \n',4,NULL),(67,99,165,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-04 10:57:07','2025-01-04 10:57:07',5,'-The author could briefly address recent measles outbreaks in Ethiopia or the study setting to highlight the urgency and importance of this study rather than mentioning global data.\n-Further elaboration on the \"inconsistent coverage\" would provide richer context. Is this inconsistency observed among African countries, or are there regions within Ethiopia with particularly low coverage?',4,'-The sampling technique and data collection methods should be mentioned.\n-Who was included in the study? all under five?',4,'The author doesn\'t provide enough statistical details, such as 95% confidence intervals for the AOR, used to assess the precision of the findings.',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(68,23,159,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-04 11:42:13','2025-01-04 11:42:13',3,'The investigator did not clearly show the knowledge gap. However, the objectives are clearly stated.',3,'The design is described and it is also appropriate to efficiently address the objectives.  The outcome variable, vaccination status is not clearly defined. Otherwise, the method section is described including, statistical procedures. The data source is also presented, self administered questionnaire. \nThe study on uptake is well investigated, and an important research approach, qualitative study, would have been addressed to complement the quantitative study.',4,'The investigator has clearly summarized the result using appropriate numerical summary measure and also compared different groups. Appropriate statistical model is also used. However, we don\'t know whether the model assumptions are checked or not.',3,'The conclusion is partly consistent with objective. The investigator missed to conclude for the second part of his/her objectives, factors associated. ',3,'This finding might be used by local implementers for planning purpose ',3,NULL),(69,60,159,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-04 12:18:42','2025-01-04 12:18:42',5,'The study addressed public health problem, and clearly stated the objectives.',3,'The study design is well stated and appropriate for the objectives. Treatment adherence need definition but not defined. The method of selecting the study institutions and two groups are not explicitly presented.',4,'The results presented following the described methods. The investigator tried to sufficiently present the result.',4,'The conclusions are as consistent with the objectives. ',3,'The investigator has tried to investigate whether there is a difference  between the two approach. But, it is not clear how the two groups selected.',4,NULL),(70,79,165,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-04 12:24:28','2025-01-04 12:24:28',4,'N/A',4,'-To my understanding, a parallel evaluation design typically refers to an experimental or quasi-experimental design where interventions or treatments are tested simultaneously. However, in this study, the authors collect data from both pilot and non-pilot facilities at the same point in time and compare the outcomes (e.g., hypertension prevention, treatment, and control) between the two groups. This makes it a comparative cross-sectional study. \n-The authors didn\'t mention the sample size and sampling technique',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(71,61,160,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-04 12:46:29','2025-01-04 12:46:29',3,'Rationale of the study is not clear\nOverall gaps of the study setting are not clear\nthe knowledge gap that led to the study is not described at all \n',2,'Independent variables are not systematically presented\nLacks adequate detail in the methods sub-section\nsample size of the participants is not clear\nCase definition is not clear \nStatistical methods are not clear  \n',1,'The study result is not logical presented\nGood to present based on the objective\nThe average of the variable is not presented by using percentage % --however, better to report using mean and standard deviation\n',2,'General pictures of the conclusion are not clear\nLack of the recommendation of the study end of the conclusion',2,'Lack of strong justification for this study\nMethodology of the study is not clear',2,NULL),(72,43,159,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-04 13:12:02','2025-01-04 13:12:02',2,'The research question is not clearly shown. But, the objectives are clearly presented',4,'The study design is appropriate for the stated objectives. However, how some variables, such as knowledge and trust are measured is not clear. ',4,'The result is presented in logical order and consistent with the objectives. ',3,'It is not clear why 84% acceptance is considered as low. Some of the issues raised in the conclusion is not consistent with the objectives',3,'It could be used as input for local health service provider, otherwise has no new finding',3,NULL),(73,79,160,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-04 13:13:43','2025-01-04 13:13:43',3,'No attention is given on the knowledge gap the study is going to add. \nRationale of the study is not described well\n',2,'Lacks adequate detail in the methods sub-section \nOverall study design is not clearly described\nEpidemiological/statistical methods not clearly described\nSample size is not clear \nStatistical procedures not described merely naming software packages',3,'How did you measure the rate of opportunistic blood pressure (BP) screening it is not clear\nThere is room for improving interpretation of data\n Why you present mean performance across the three domains by proportion this is the conflicting results (76.1% vs. 51.2%).',3,'This conclusion is not clear ---the evaluation of the pilot hypertension program in the Amhara region of Ethiopia demonstrated promising results.---good to write just exact figures\nSome of the texts are simply repeating of the results\n',4,'No attention is given on the knowledge gap the study is going to add',4,NULL),(74,98,160,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-04 13:38:48','2025-01-04 13:38:48',3,'Public health problem that questions that the study was addressed is not clear\nExisting gaps is not clearly described at all\nknowledge gaps of the study are not considered',2,'Methodology is not comprehensive \nLacks adequate detail in the methods \nMeasurement and category of the variables is not clear\nStatistical software is not clear\nStatistical analysis is not described well\nMethodology of the study are superficial, does not tell how each variable had been measured\n',2,'This result is not clear --Analysis revealed a significant increase in controlled DM cases, rising from zero in 2019-2020 to 1,258 in 2022-2023---how many percentages that increased??\nPercentage of the data do not allow the reader to reach a conclusion\n',2,'synthesis of the conclusion is not based on the results\nAuthors synthesize results into a conclusion is not clear\nNo exact figure results under conclusion',3,'it needs strong justification of this study',3,NULL),(75,115,160,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-04 14:03:24','2025-01-04 14:03:24',4,'But the knowledge gap that led to the study is not described at all \n',4,'overall methods is not adequately described \nContents of some of the methods not presented well\nModel diagnostic criteria is not presented   \n',4,'How did you measure poor knowledge on scabies and not clear\nThere is room for improving interpretation of data considering comparison groups\n',4,'N/A',3,'It needs strong justification for the study',4,NULL),(76,18,142,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 04:14:18','2025-01-05 04:14:18',2,'The background is written in a way that makes it seem like the assessment was on \'surveillance\' rather than \'surveillance system evaluation\'. e.g. \"Hypertension surveillance plays a crucial role \"\nThe author/s didn`t put the significance of evaluating both private and public health facilities together.  ',2,'The study design was not mentioned. In addition, the authors didn`t mention the sample size for the record review/quantitative study that was entered into EPIINFO and analyzed with stata. They mentioned only for qualitative. why the evaluated public and private health facilities together? ',3,'The author reported in the method section that they used both percentages and proportions. However, it is not clear why they mentioned reporting both, and also unclear which one they used in reporting results. ',3,'The authors concluded the \'unstable of the system due to lack of dedicated resources\'. However, issues related to resource/s were not reported in the result section so the conclusion is based on results. ',2,'Such a study should be well designed so that appropriate public health significance would be indicated. ',3,NULL),(77,38,142,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 04:37:40','2025-01-05 04:37:40',3,'The way the background was written seems as if the study was conducted on the impacts of social determinants on  hypertension mortality...... \".........impact of social determinants on hypertension-related mortality is poorly understood......\"\nThat means the gap is not clearly identified. ',4,'The authors didn`t mention which logistic regression was employed. The study population is missed. The author didn\'t mention what type of population was included in their study (is not found in the objective and method section also)',5,'N/A',4,'The authors forwarded recommendations for only health professionals. ',4,'The authors forwarded recommendations for only health professionals. ',4,NULL),(78,55,142,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 04:56:00','2025-01-05 04:56:00',3,'The way the background was written seems as if it was aimed to focus on new HIV infections. \".......new infections continue to pose a major public health challenge\"',5,'well written ',2,'The expected key finding of this study, 5 years trend, was not reported. They reported the magnitude of HIV within those 5 years and among males and females as well as in place only. ',3,'Trend isn\'t concluded, wether it was increasing or decreasing ',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(79,71,142,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 05:11:37','2025-01-05 05:11:37',3,'The objective is not well-written ',3,'the sample size included was not mentioned. Only 45 health facilities included in the study were mentioned. \nEthical issue is not expected to be written under the abstract. ',3,'The way the results are narrated lacks clarity. Besides, a new sentence should not start by number....\"61.57% of cases were......\"',4,'No recommendation was made for the high prevalence of HIV in urban settings. ',4,NULL,3,NULL),(80,91,142,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 05:42:29','2025-01-05 05:42:29',3,'The study gap was not well identified ',2,'The study compared insured and non-insured populations. However, the study design employed was cross-section. why they didn`t employ comparative cross-sectional? They employed chi-square and logistic regression together. They used also convenience sampling which is non-probability sampling. ',4,'The way the Adjusted odds ratio is interpreted is not clear. ',2,'Since appropriate study design and sampling were employed, the conclusion and recommendation made from this study aren`t scientifically sound. ',3,'since proper sampling and design were not utilized, we can`t conclude that this study has public health significance. ',3,NULL),(81,109,142,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 06:01:04','2025-01-05 06:01:04',2,'The objective mentioned is not supposed to be addressed by a case-control study. ',2,'The objective was magnitude and associated factors which is expected to be addressed by cross-sectional study. Hence, the objective and design employed, case-control, don`t match. ',1,'The study objective was the magnitude and associated factors. But they utilized case-control study. Hover, in the result they reported the incidence rate which is supposed to be reported if a cohort study was used. They calculated 50 sample size for cases but they recruited 1,267  for cases. ',2,'Is not based on results. ',2,'Is not based on proper design and results found. ',1,NULL),(82,23,25,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 06:16:39','2025-01-05 06:16:39',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',3,'N/A',5,NULL),(83,42,25,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 06:23:49','2025-01-05 06:23:49',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(84,46,25,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 06:35:25','2025-01-05 06:35:25',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(85,62,25,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 06:42:58','2025-01-05 06:42:58',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(86,78,25,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 06:49:53','2025-01-05 06:49:53',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(87,98,25,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 06:54:43','2025-01-05 06:54:43',2,'N/A',1,'N/A',2,'N/A',3,'N/A',2,'N/A',0,NULL),(88,115,25,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 07:57:26','2025-01-05 07:57:26',4,'N/A',3,'Who are cases and whoare controls?',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,NULL),(89,49,23,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 08:49:16','2025-01-05 08:49:16',4,'Although the background is well-written, it would be more impactful if it included some statistical data regarding the MPDSR problem in the area.',4,'It would be better to use qualitative data analysis software rather than conducting it manually.',4,'It\'s only focused on the quantitative result. What about the qualitative findings? ',5,'The conclusions and recommendations are clear and directly associated with the findings that are mentioned under the results section, and it will have a good impact for the region. ',4,'It will have a great impact on the future improvement of this gap in the region as well as at the national level. ',5,NULL),(90,82,167,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 09:11:04','2025-01-05 09:11:04',5,'N/A',5,'The study is well-described, but lacks explicit definitions of key terms and a concise explanation of statistical methods, such as model selection steps.',5,'N/A',5,'The conclusions and interpretations are well-described, but the specific recommended strategy and the responsible bodies for implementation are not clearly identified.',4,'The study recommends a salt intake reduction strategy, but no specific public health actions have been implemented. Targeted interventions, such as education campaigns or policy changes, could significantly reduce excessive salt intake in Bahir Dar City and similar areas.',5,NULL),(91,72,23,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 12:45:17','2025-01-05 12:45:17',4,'The problems of schistosomiasis, geohelminthiasis, and anemia are well addressed by associating the problems with IDPs.',5,'The method is well described. \n\n',5,'The results section is well written.',5,'The conclusion and interpretation of the study describe a lot of things. ',5,'This study provides insightful information about the Neglected Tropical Disease. ',5,NULL),(92,20,144,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 14:47:14','2025-01-05 14:47:14',3,'The author tried to describe the problem statement. Its significance or key antecedent data was not well described.  However, some writing styles need to be improved. eg. the word \'describe\' inappropriately used in \"Hence, this evaluation aims to describe the implementation status of the system, describe the attributes........, describe the knowledge of healthcare providers, and describe......................',3,'The importance of calculating sample size \"70 case report forms (CRF) samples were calculated using a single population proportion formula\" was not clear in the sense that single population proportion context.',3,'How the overall implementation status of the HIV CS system was measured?',3,'N/A',2,'Some recommendations are not derived directly from study results. eg. The overall implementation status of the HIV CS system is not sufficient compared to the regional and national targets.',3,NULL),(93,42,144,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 15:17:51','2025-01-05 15:17:51',3,'The author has tried to describe the magnitude of the problem. However, The background has unnecessary details. eg. In 2016, approximately 1.13 billion adults were affected by hypertension, with about 7.5 million deaths attributed to it globally in 2021. ',3,'N/A',2,'Some of the data presented in the result section were not supported by the figure (data) except for completeness and timelines. Summarizing in proportions is important.',3,'Surveillance system attributes were not described quantitatively. eg proportion of .......',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(94,64,163,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 17:57:51','2025-01-05 17:57:51',4,'The scientific background and the significance of the public health should be mentioned ',4,'The method of summarizing the results should be mentioned.\nthe case definitions should be also mentioned',4,'The total participants the study should be mentioned as it is. it could be in rates/percents',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(95,71,8,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 18:05:05','2025-01-05 18:05:05',4,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,'The conclusions are not based on strong epidemiological evidence',2,'N/A',3,NULL),(96,93,8,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 18:09:45','2025-01-05 18:09:45',3,'No justification provided ',2,'No case definition, only descriptive analysis. No advanced epidemiology methods employed. ',2,'Only number of cases is reported and described. No proportions were discussed. ',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(97,109,8,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 18:11:35','2025-01-05 18:11:35',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,NULL),(98,103,163,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-05 18:15:39','2025-01-05 18:15:39',4,'The scientific and significance of the public health problems should be mentioned. the literature review of the public health problem should be mentioned ',5,NULL,5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(99,14,138,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-06 06:35:32','2025-01-06 06:35:32',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(100,33,138,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-06 06:54:06','2025-01-06 06:54:06',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,NULL),(101,53,138,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-06 07:13:02','2025-01-06 07:13:02',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(102,72,138,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-06 07:20:04','2025-01-06 07:20:04',4,'N/A',3,'There is information about sample size, sampling procedure and study settings clearly.',3,'All the stated objectives were not responded or there is no result for all specifice objectives.',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(103,12,14,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-06 07:37:34','2025-01-06 07:37:34',3,'NCD  data and information of Ethiopia were not well addressed,the objective was not explicitly stated',5,'N/A',4,'age ,sex and other factors association with NCD were not explicitly stated',4,'N/A',4,'public health significance  were not that much emphasized',4,NULL),(104,91,138,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-06 07:40:26','2025-01-06 07:40:26',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(105,30,14,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-06 07:46:10','2025-01-06 07:46:10',3,'global situation was not captured as background',5,'well addressed',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(106,46,14,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-06 07:57:10','2025-01-06 07:57:10',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(107,71,14,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-06 08:02:05','2025-01-06 08:02:05',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(108,86,14,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-06 08:08:02','2025-01-06 08:08:02',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'not well stated according to the objective',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(109,90,23,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-06 08:23:42','2025-01-06 08:23:42',3,'It lacks statistical data to elaborate on the public health issues of Visceral Leishmaniasis and other parasitic infections. ',3,'This study only uses binary logistic regression to determine the risk factor for VL. It will be better to consider multiple logistic regression to consider the effect of confounding. ',5,'The study has well-written results. ',4,'Better to consider specific recommendations regarding the issues.',4,'When we see the VL issues, it\'s only observed in a limited area. ',4,NULL),(110,102,14,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-06 08:25:24','2025-01-06 08:25:24',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'the important intervention for TB prevention was not well stated',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(111,109,23,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-06 08:41:34','2025-01-06 08:41:34',5,' The issue is entertained from global to local presentation with statistical figures. ',4,'The method section is good; however, it lacks clarification between bivariable and bivariate logistic regression. ',5,'The result section is well described. ',5,'The conclusion includes general and specific recommendations.',4,'Even if the recommendations are not new, it will help as a reminder. ',5,NULL),(112,110,138,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-06 09:02:44','2025-01-06 09:02:44',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,NULL),(113,114,159,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-06 12:20:11','2025-01-06 12:20:11',3,'It is well known that the topic of interest is a public health problem in Ethiopia. The objective of the study is presented. However, the reason for conducting this study was not clearly indicated. ',3,'The investigator has described the study design. The stated study design, can\'t answer all of the objectives. For example, verifying the existence of an outbreak can\'t be addressed by case-control study.',4,'The results are present in a logical flow. It is not clear, whether the two groups are comparable or not ',3,'Conclusion is partly based the data.',3,'The finding could be taken into account by local implementers',4,NULL),(114,57,144,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-06 14:49:13','2025-01-06 14:49:13',1,'Not written in the Abstract protocol ( some contents were directly taken from the Internet (International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 2019, 31(10), G180–G186doi: 10.1093/intqhc/mzz127)',1,'Too large to capture, Not written in the Abstract protocol ( some contents were directly taken from the Internet (International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 2019, 31(10), G180–G186doi: 10.1093/intqhc/mzz127)',1,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,'N/A',1,NULL),(115,13,122,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-06 20:46:25','2025-01-06 20:46:25',3,'The public health problem is described but the objective is not described and rationale for the study is mentioned',2,'The objective is described in the method section, the method is not descriptive enough and period of the study is incorrect ',4,'The cause of the landslide is not mentioned as described in the methods but otherwise the impact is mentioned in logical sequence',1,'The conclusion doesn\'t seem to have connection with the result, and it has also components of the result section and it is not quite clear what kind of message the writer wanted to conclude with this conclusion ',2,'Beyond describing the disaster, the message from the writer based on the findings is not clear and it didn\'t add much knowledge or create new knowledge for others',3,NULL),(116,21,151,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 03:16:25','2025-01-07 03:16:25',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(117,39,151,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 04:59:52','2025-01-07 04:59:52',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(118,56,151,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 05:04:59','2025-01-07 05:04:59',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',2,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(119,76,151,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 05:12:31','2025-01-07 05:12:31',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(120,95,151,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 05:16:31','2025-01-07 05:16:31',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(121,113,151,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 05:20:41','2025-01-07 05:20:41',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(122,31,159,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 07:56:42','2025-01-07 07:56:42',5,'The objectives are clearly presented, and the problem studied is also priority public health issue that need investigation',4,'The design is ok for the intended objectives. It would have been nice if mixed approach was applied (both qualitative and quantitative)',4,'Results presented in logical order in line with the stated objectives. The statistical method is also appropriate',5,'Great',5,'This is an important part which has been neglected. The finding could be an input to give due attention to strengthen health institution capacity',4,NULL),(123,97,159,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 08:08:01','2025-01-07 08:08:01',3,'Objective is described\nThe reason why they did the study looks not clear',5,'Design is appropriate \nStatistical method briefly presented\nData source is clearly stated',4,'Appropriate quantitative method used to summarize the finding\nWhat is presented here focus only on the clinical and few environmental factors',4,'Concluded for variables that were not shown in this abstract. Ex:. vector factor?\nThe conclusion should be consistent with the objective and finding of this abstract\n ',5,'Highly relevant for the local health service provider, researcher and top managers',4,NULL),(124,68,126,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 08:17:13','2025-01-07 08:17:13',3,'The rationale or the justification for the evaluation was mentioned to be lack of information whether the CBS is effective or not. However, the objectives did not address it.',3,'It is not clear how the core surveillance activities and attributes of surveillance system were measured and analyzed. How did they assess the number of cases reported? Were they also assessed using questionnaire? Did they conduct record review to see the cases being reported through the system?',3,'The results did not follow logical order in terms of number of participants, and also what are described in the methods section. For instance, medians, interquartile ranges and frequencies were mentioned in the methods section but no result was reported using these analysis methods.',3,'Based on the comments I made above; it is hard to know whether the problem and objectives are addressed or not. The conclusion looks simply repetition of the results.',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(125,78,159,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 08:19:24','2025-01-07 08:19:24',3,'The objective is clear. But, the way research problem stated is not transparent.',4,'The stated design is appropriate for the proposed problem. However, the status need clear definition. For example, when did you categorize achieved BB control?',4,'Result is concise, and consistent with objective and method.',4,'Better to make this concise',4,'This section is also ok',4,NULL),(126,106,126,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 09:01:14','2025-01-07 09:01:14',4,'The need for the study and the objectives are clear.',4,'The statistical methods were well described. However, the type of statistical software was not mentioned.',3,'The comparison between the number of new cases in 2020 with 2024 is not clear-- their plan was to do percentage not cases per population. Have you checked for distribution of age (symmetrical) to use mean instead of median? In addition, it is good to be consistent in presenting results (AOR) for both variables.',2,'\"The trends of both newly identified and recent HIV infections were decreasing since 2022\" was not based on the data presented in the result section. There is no evidence whether the new cases were decreasing as of 2022. In addition, there was no information about the \"recent infection\" trend at all.',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(127,23,156,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 11:15:50','2025-01-07 11:15:50',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'should have address response rate, the first sentence is vague. ',4,'Good and bad classification is not well described.',5,'N/A',5,NULL),(128,39,156,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 11:19:44','2025-01-07 11:19:44',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'Nothing was described about v.cholera identification when the resident concluded about it.',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(129,59,156,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 11:28:25','2025-01-07 11:28:25',4,'the objective is not fully representative of the title of the abstract.',4,'It is no research project, but the finding sounded like a research investigation.',3,'N/A',3,'not presented about water availablity in a result.',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(130,101,167,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 14:52:46','2025-01-07 14:52:46',2,'The study would benefit from a more detailed description of malaria\'s disease patterns and its occurrence specifically in West Arsi, Oromia, and Ethiopia. Additionally, the study objectives should align more closely with the title, as they are more specific than what the title suggests. Furthermore, while the title focuses on the trend and pattern of the disease, the background section only addresses the burden of the disease, lacking a focus on the trends and patterns.',2,'The study design and participant selection process are not clearly outlined. Critical definitions, such as \"confirmed malaria cases,\" are not explicitly provided, nor is there sufficient explanation of how cases were included or excluded. Additionally, the statistical methods and techniques are not adequately described.',4,'The numerical comparisons are correct and clearly presented, though the inclusion of more methodological details could improve the overall clarity.',2,'The interpretation and conclusion are not fully supported by the data presented in the results section. For example, the prevalence of Plasmodium falciparum is not mentioned in the results, and comparisons between geographic areas with different denominators make it difficult to draw meaningful conclusions. Overall, the interpretation lacks focus and specificity, and does not adequately reflect the data.',2,'N/A',2,NULL),(131,80,168,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 16:44:42','2025-01-07 16:44:42',2,'The background is not clearly stated. There are some information which looks like result in the background. The background is not precise and concise. It is written haphazardly.    ',2,'The method stated multiple methodologies was used (both qualitative and quantitative study designs). But it stated it used Simple random sampling for all methodologies including for qualitative design. There are several contradicting information in this document ',2,'I don\'t think the authors clearly understood what we mean by abstract. The result part of this abstract is not clearly thoughted approach to write result in abstract. there are too much words and information with some redundancies. It is four paragraphs in total. ',1,'I don\'t believe this is a way to write conclusion. there are redundancies in the conclusion as well as the background and results part.  ',3,'Despite public health significance this study lacks the scientific integrity and quality',2,NULL),(132,26,168,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 16:53:18','2025-01-07 16:53:18',4,'The objective of this study is clearly justified in the background of this study. ',3,'The methodology lacks detail and clarity. It is very shallow. It should at least indicate the design for qualitative and quantitative methods, population selection, sample size, sampling and key data analysis approach for both designs ',3,'This study also lack detail for the results. It has highlighted only major findings without clarity. It should indicate key findings from both qualitative and quantitative results  ',3,'This study conclusion also lack the objective of the study. It should summarize key findings with its implications and provide recommendations based on the findings ',4,'This study focused on one of the major public health issues (malaria). It incorporated lab investigations which increase the validity of the measurements.  I would recommend it for either poster presentation or oral written presentations, but it should improve the quality of the information in the abstract ',4,NULL),(133,45,168,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-07 17:03:39','2025-01-07 17:03:39',4,'This study focused on one of the rising global public health issue including in Ethiopia. ',3,'The methods part lack information on how they triangulated all the data sources (monthly government health facilities report, non-communicable disease surveillance reports, and the Demographic Health Information System 2 (DHIS2) database). What is the difference between monthly government health facilities report and DHIS2? Who were the population group? what was the sampling methods? ',3,'This study is simple descriptive data/information.',3,'the study indicated rising diabetes case and recommended more screening. I don\'t think this is the appropriate recommendation for rising diabetes cases. It should recommended management and interventions to decrease or halt the rise in diabetes cases. ',3,'Despite relevance of this topic, it lacks details and analytical quality.  ',3,NULL),(134,15,132,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 07:12:59','2025-01-08 07:12:59',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(135,33,132,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 07:15:50','2025-01-08 07:15:50',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(136,72,143,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 07:23:48','2025-01-08 07:23:48',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',2,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(137,36,134,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 07:36:06','2025-01-08 07:36:06',4,'The study partially addressed the public health problem with limitation in clearly stating the objective  of the study. however the results presented  are not addressed about IPC related indicators. Additionally the  conclusion part is not written proporly.',5,NULL,3,'The way the result presented is not as per the intended objective. expected preliminary independent variables are not addressed. ',4,'Even though there are some missed variables like infection prevention  that are expected to be presented in the result were missed the investigator try to make the result consistent to the current scientific knowledge. How ever the conclusion part doesnot aproprietly inline with the stated objective.  ',3,'Of course  yes it can solve. But in order to implement the results  presented in the in the abstract it needs extra investigation. some of them are not the immediate causes. so with its limitation it is help full  for extra investigation and to take action on the mentioned one. This finding can be use full for the facility where the study is conducted and other similar facilities.',4,NULL),(138,60,168,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 07:37:07','2025-01-08 07:37:07',4,'The authors clearly indicated the objective of this study. It compared a model for improving adherence ',1,'I don\'t think the authors used an appropriate study design to compare between two groups (between appointment spacing model users and non-users). It should have been analytic study designs such as Case control which compares outcome or exposure among groups. Moreover, we usually use case control to study determinants of outcome variables. ',3,'The results are somewhat stated concisely. But this study should have compared exposure and outcome between groups using other study designs. ',2,'The conclusion lacks specificity and implication of the findings. It also lack statement on how to address the problem identified. ',4,'HIV is one of the Public health issues nationally and internationally. It also fit this EFELTP conference as it is one of the track for field epidemiology students. ',3,NULL),(139,82,168,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 07:48:44','2025-01-08 07:48:44',2,'The title and the objectives are not clearly stated. The title states about salt reduction (we don\'t know whether it is salt reduction knowledge, attitude or practice) while the objective stated salt reduction practice. ',2,'I don\'t believe malti-stage sampling for a community based study within a single city is appropriate sampling strategy. There are many vague sentences in the methods. \"Finally, variables with a p-value of 0.05 and a 95% confidence interval (CI) not included were used to declare statistically significant variables\". This statement is not clear!',3,'N/A',3,'The recommendation should be specific \"Therefore, a salt intake reduction practice strategy is highly recommended\". What are those strategies ',1,'N/A',2,NULL),(140,75,132,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 07:59:30','2025-01-08 07:59:30',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(141,59,154,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:01:40','2025-01-08 08:01:40',3,'of course , they had tried to express the side effect of the drought when observed  but it is not appropriately described the objectives elements what did you want described? simply it was mentioned describe what elements?. And also no feasible and not described the rational of the study?',2,'N/A',2,'It was not coherence the idea and not matched the results and set of objective. not more elaborated the result of findings',2,'It was not directly specific to their findings , rather it is the general facts about the drought. they weren\'t recommended intervention activities based on the results for specific sectors in their study area.',2,'Not gave specific recommendation based on the results',1,NULL),(142,87,173,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:03:56','2025-01-08 08:03:56',4,'Public health problem is indicated, Objective is also stated',5,'Method is clear and appropriate ',4,'Only significant variables are presented Hower it is important that some epidemiology (e.g. epidemic curve) parameters are included',3,'Policy implication is not stated',5,'Since this is outbreak investigation, it is very important for further study and program ',4,NULL),(143,48,132,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:04:11','2025-01-08 08:04:11',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(144,67,173,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:06:42','2025-01-08 08:06:42',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'Those other areas are unknow. Policy implications are not included ',3,'N/A',4,NULL),(145,89,132,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:06:44','2025-01-08 08:06:44',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,NULL),(146,98,154,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:07:07','2025-01-08 08:07:07',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,NULL),(147,50,173,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:07:53','2025-01-08 08:07:53',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',2,'N/A',0,'N/A',3,NULL),(148,31,173,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:08:47','2025-01-08 08:08:47',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,NULL),(149,108,132,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:09:51','2025-01-08 08:09:51',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(150,79,154,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:11:05','2025-01-08 08:11:05',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,NULL),(151,92,143,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:16:36','2025-01-08 08:16:36',2,'N/A',0,'N/A',1,'N/A',1,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,NULL),(152,14,131,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:19:50','2025-01-08 08:19:50',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,'N/A',3,NULL),(153,50,134,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:20:35','2025-01-08 08:20:35',4,'In this study since TB is among the determinant public health problems the investigator try to show the situation of TB detraction rate. How ever, the objective simply looks like collecting and compiling report. it does not go beyond to identify the determinant factors for the enablers and barriers of detecting activity. ',4,'although descriptive study was conducted the study design was not well described. It also addressed the objective of the study.  The author   does not  explain the software used for analysis. ',4,'The result part of this study was logically follow the described method, but  determinate factors are not described  and identified. nothing is said about the  expected interventions. ',5,'Though it looks like a performance report and the factors for this low performance were not considered. The presented descriptive results were well presented. ',5,'as per to the finding the overall TB case detection rate was 26% which is very  low. its public health significance is clear. It is also helpful clue for giving concern in the performance and take an improvement actions. the limitation of the abstract is not clearly adressing the determinat factors and their association with the dependant variable. ',5,NULL),(154,32,131,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:22:36','2025-01-08 08:22:36',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(155,47,131,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:28:49','2025-01-08 08:28:49',3,'This assessment missed Objective ',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',2,'There was no indicative  about risk of disease outbreak in the result section, should conclude based on the findings',2,'N/A',3,NULL),(156,70,131,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:31:05','2025-01-08 08:31:05',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,NULL),(157,88,131,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:33:23','2025-01-08 08:33:23',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(158,99,168,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:33:35','2025-01-08 08:33:35',4,'N/A',2,'The methods lack detail for study period, sampling, total sample, data analysis approach. It would have been better if they used mixed methods (qualitative and quantitative) for the factors affecting uptake. It should have indicated the source of data (secondary vs primary or checked vaccination card) ',3,'The study didn\'t state any information about under five years of age children who were the study units. The results also lack detail about demographic. It should have triangulated factors hindering MCV2 uptake with qualitative data. ',2,'The statement \"MCV2 coverage in Durame town, while improving, is still below the WHO target of ≥ 95%\" is not within the scope of the study. This study didn\'t include change in improvement in MCV2. If so, it should have indicated the change in improvement overtime (either time series analysis or trend analysis should have been used)',4,'Measles infection is and endemic public health concerns affecting thousands of children in Ethiopia. It is also one of the Ethiopian public health policy direction to reduce measles through EPI program ',3,NULL),(159,110,143,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:36:04','2025-01-08 08:36:04',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',2,'N/A',3,NULL),(160,107,131,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:36:05','2025-01-08 08:36:05',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(161,91,134,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 08:59:00','2025-01-08 08:59:00',4,'The objective and abstract title naming It is better to say outcome evaluation than impact evaluation. because out come evaluation is narrower in scope,while impact evaluation covers broader and long term change. the other one is time frame; outcomes are typically assessed shortly after program completion, while impacts may take years to measure. This abstract is limited with resource and time to conduct the evaluation. ',5,'N/A',5,'The result is presented in a well defined way. However, the term prevalence in the prevalence of good medication adherence is not right word. In stead better to use the term uptake or acceptance. ',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,NULL),(162,17,141,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 09:00:02','2025-01-08 09:00:02',2,'The background information does not hel the reader envisage what the investigator is going to address with the research. The investigator focused on describing what surveillance is than the surveillance system. The investigator also did not clearly indicate the research gap: why he was interested to evaluate the surveillance system. ',2,'The study approach the investigator used is not to the standard. The malaria surveillance system should address the three dimension of the surveillance systemen evaluation: the core functions of the malaria surveillance system, the supportive function of the surveillance system, and the attributives of the surveillance system. He did not comprehensively address them all',1,'The result of the malaria surveillance system should address the core function of the surveillance system, the supportive function of the surveillance system, and the attributives of the surveillance system. Non of these three dimension is appropriately addressed. ',0,'The conclusion is not based on the study finding',5,'The area of the study is very instrumental to the national malaria control and elimination strategy',2,NULL),(163,32,141,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 09:22:26','2025-01-08 09:22:26',4,'The background of the study is informative',2,'The title of the study indicates that the investigator is interested to amalaria outbreak investigation. However, the study method/approach is all about identifying the determinants of the outbreak than investigating the occurance of the outbreak. The researcher did not tell us the occurance of the outbreak and how he/she did investigate it; rather, he/she focused on the analytical study (unmatched case control study) to identify the determinants of the outbreak',4,'The result part is well written',2,'The recommendation is not based on the result of the study. The recommendation should also be specific',5,'The area is to priotity problem of the country',3,NULL),(164,77,140,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 09:24:11','2025-01-08 09:24:11',2,'First, thank you for providing me this chance to give my comment. I would like to comment this abstract as follows; The author clearly stated the objective of the study in the  background part of this abstract. But the definition of the public health surveillance is not correct and as a general comment also related to this section, I would give my comment in detail in the last part of the evaluation criteria \"Overall clarity of the abstract\"',3,'This methodology section shows that the study design is not adequately explained and is not suitable to meet the study objectives. It is not indicated what statistical method or procedure was employed in this investigation, nor even what software was used.',2,'The study results are not summarized and described appropriately. The data presentation is not detailed and adequate to allow the readers to reach a conclusion.',2,'The conclusion and interpretation is not based on the data presented and addressed the problem of the study. The study dose not appear sufficiently valid and reliable for taking the public health action. ',1,'The public health significant of the study do not solve the problem. The author didn\'t put his recommendation and any action those derived from the study result. This shows that it is completed.',2,NULL),(165,32,141,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 09:24:54','2025-01-08 09:24:54',4,'The background of the study is informative',2,'The title of the study indicates that the investigator is interested to amalaria outbreak investigation. However, the study method/approach is all about identifying the determinants of the outbreak than investigating the occurance of the outbreak. The researcher did not tell us the occurance of the outbreak and how he/she did investigate it; rather, he/she focused on the analytical study (unmatched case control study) to identify the determinants of the outbreak',4,'The result part is well written',2,'The recommendation is not based on the result of the study. The recommendation should also be specific',5,'The area is to priotity problem of the country',3,NULL),(166,37,141,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 09:48:41','2025-01-08 09:48:41',4,'The background is informative',3,'The investigator used multilevel sampling technique, and did not consider that laveles/hierachies in the analysis part',4,'The result is well presented',4,'The conclusion is based on the finding of the result',5,'The area is among the top priority proble of the country',4,NULL),(167,16,140,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 10:26:21','2025-01-08 10:26:21',4,'First, I would like to say thank you for adding my comment on this abstract. As comments, the authors clearly stated the problems, and the objective is appropriate to address the problem.',4,'The study design is appropriate and efficient to address the study objective. The statistical method and procedures for this study are clearly stated and described in this methods part of the abstract. ',4,'The study results follow the method described and are summarized using appropriate quantitative measures and presented in a sufficient manner. ',5,'The conclusion and interpretation addressed the problems and objectives of the study and were valid and reliable to serve as a base for public health actions. ',4,'The authors provided recommendations based on the findings or derived directly from their study results.',4,NULL),(168,27,163,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 10:57:14','2025-01-08 10:57:14',5,'the objectives of the study needs refinement',5,'N/A',3,'The total number of study participants should be mentioned. the baseline also should be presented. The disease age classification should follows the standards. in case of descriptive epidemiology it should be clearly stating in the case of Time, Place and persons,... so on. Finally, the Data should be adequate. ',3,'the conclusion should based on the results from the study objectives. ',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(169,83,163,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 11:35:05','2025-01-08 11:35:05',4,'in the result part there are results that shows the magnitude of the problem. so the objective should be revised as per the results. the rumor source and how they handled the issues should be incorporated. how the team were deployed also elaborated. Ideally, it is better to start the study by describing the cases from line lists and then from the analysis of the cases what the risk factors of the outbreak hypothesized and the analytic parts continued.',5,'The source of the study questionairy should be mentioned. ',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,NULL),(170,25,161,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 12:07:01','2025-01-08 12:07:01',4,'N/A',3,'There is no clear deffinition for cases and controls\nThe method section merely name the software packages but not specific description of the statistical procedures applied ',4,'It would have been better if the result of the descriptive study was presented first and followed by the result related with the case control study ',3,'The conclusion was almost repetition of the result. In addition, the result only indicate who were the high risk groups for example those who didn’t use ITN. However, the authors recommended improving awareness while there was no result that indicate the ITN utilization was due to lack of information or lack of ITN itself. ',3,'N/A',4,NULL),(171,42,161,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 12:14:43','2025-01-08 12:14:43',4,'Background was written well and only miss the description that link the evaluation and the disease burden',3,'The method didn\'t indicate specific indicators measured and the statistical method used',3,'There are contrudicting results like low rate of compeleteness while the system was reported as simple ',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(172,53,141,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 12:21:22','2025-01-08 12:21:22',3,'The objective is not inline with the title of the study. The title is about Cholera outbreak investigation which has its own protocol; however, the objective of the study is merely about identifying the risk factors. ',3,'The methodological approach is again not inline with the title of the study. Cholera outbreak investigation is addressed using both descriptive ( to investigate an outbreak) and analytical (to identify the determinants) approach. However, in this manuscrip, the method is only for the analytical (identifying the determinants) part',4,'The result is well presented ',4,'The conclusion is inline with the result',4,'The problem is among the major public health problems',4,NULL),(173,110,134,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 12:21:46','2025-01-08 12:21:46',4,'The objective of the study is to evaluate the  hypertension surveillance system of Addis Ababa,Ethiopia. Nothing is mentioned  about injuries & Mental Health both in the background and result part. However, in the sub them section injuries & Mental Health are mentioned which is unnecessary.  ',4,'The methodology part was well stated and try to address the objective. But, since the data was collected using key informant interview by selecting a single participant from each selected facility, the saturation of collected information is doubtful. In the data collection method, it said descriptive cross sectional,while  the data was collected using semi structured questioner by interviewing key informants.Nothing is  mentioned about the strength and drowback system established as poilot. ',5,'N/A',5,'The result is presented and described very well. Even though the data specifically  related to the system is not clearly collected and  identified in detail the perception and opinion  of the key informants is presented. ',4,'The objective of the abstract and what is written in the conclusion part are not strongly aligned. in the objective and result part nothing is listed about the status of  detecting morbidity and retaining patients on treatment. on the other hand in the conclusion part it is mentioned as key issue. ',3,NULL),(174,62,161,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 12:21:55','2025-01-08 12:21:55',5,'N/A',4,'Some methods described in this section (Kruskal-Wallis test, Spearman correlation test) didn\'t have any result related or perforemed by using them ',4,'There were no results for some of the methods described in the method section (Kruskal-Wallis test, Spearman correlation test)',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(175,70,141,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 12:30:08','2025-01-08 12:30:08',3,'The objective of the study is not inline with the title of the study. Measles outbreak investigation has both the descriptive (to investigate an outbreak) and the analytical (to identify determinants of the outbreak) objectives. The manuscript is all about identifying determinants of measles outbreak. ',3,'The approach should include both descriptive and analytical part',4,'The result is inline with the stated objective and method',5,'The conclusion is inline with the result of the study',5,'The problem is among the top public health priority problems',4,NULL),(176,81,161,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 12:31:47','2025-01-08 12:31:47',4,'N/A',3,'There was results from descriptive studies but the method only described the case control design ',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(177,101,161,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 12:36:07','2025-01-08 12:36:07',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(178,116,161,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 12:39:51','2025-01-08 12:39:51',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(179,90,141,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 12:44:57','2025-01-08 12:44:57',4,'The background of the study is very precise and helps the reader envisage what is going to be addressed with the study',4,'The investigator did not consider the stages/hierarchies in the data analyis part',4,'The result is well written',5,'The conclusion is inline with the findings of the study',4,'The problem is among the top national priority problems',5,NULL),(180,36,140,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 14:14:19','2025-01-08 14:14:19',3,'I would like to thank you for providing this chance to review this abstract. Following the revision of this abstract in detail, these are some of my comments based on the criteria. My comments on the introduction part of this abstract concern only the fact that the public health problem is not stated clearly.',3,'The study design is appropriate and efficient to address the study objectives stated in the introduction part. The critical definitions clearly are stated. The statistical method and procedures for this study are also clearly stated and described in this part of the abstract methods. But the data source is not stated. ',4,'The study results follow the method they described and are summarized using appropriate quantitative measures and presented in a sufficient manner. ',3,'The conclusion and interpretation addressed the problems and objectives of the study and were valid and reliable to serve as a base for public health actions. ',3,'The authors provided recommendations based on the findings derived directly from their study results. However, there is a limitation on the recommendations part and needs more recommendation. ',3,NULL),(181,56,140,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 14:57:41','2025-01-08 14:57:41',3,'First, I would like to say thank you for adding my comment on this abstract. As comments, the authors clearly stated the problems, and the objective is appropriate to address the problem.',2,'The study design is appropriate and efficient to address the study objective. However, the critical definitions are not stated. I addition, the statistical method and procedures for this study are not detailly stated and described in the method part of this abstract. ',3,'The study results follow the method described and are summarized using appropriate quantitative measures and presented in a sufficient manner.  But it lucks the adequate data presentation to allow the readers to reach a conclusion. ',3,'The conclusion and interpretation of this abstract do not address the problems and objectives of the study and is not also valid and reliable to serve as a base for public health actions.',2,'The authors provided recommendations. But the recommendations are not based on the findings derived directly from their study results. In genera there is a limitation on the recommendations part.',2,NULL),(182,108,141,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 15:34:56','2025-01-08 15:34:56',4,'The background of the broblem is written well',2,'Retrospective cohort study is more appropriate design for this study as the records of the required variables is available',4,'The objective of the study is fully addressed in the result part',2,'The conclusion of the study finding is not inline with result. The finding is not consistent with the 2025 targeted 95-95-95 goal',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(183,52,174,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-08 18:33:18','2025-01-08 18:33:18',3,'N/A-The study addresses that measles is the public health problem/study was conducted five-year measles surveillance data /Objective of the study was stated that to outline the epidemiology of measles on surveillance and laboratory findings',2,'N/A, The study title is Measles outbreak investigation, however based on the background and Method the title showed be Five years Measles surveillance data analysis,\nTo address the objective the study design is appropriate, critical definitions not clearly defined but the statistical methods concisely described  \nThe study population and data source were clearly stated',3,'N/A-Study result logically follow and described methods/Result summarized using appropriate quantitative/qualitative measures, but place of findings not mentioned, during study period surveillance data reported was only 48 and the numerical comparison was correct and appropriate ',2,'N/A-the conclusion and interpretation were based on data presented/but not address the problem and objectives/also the study was not sufficiently valid and reliable to serve as a basis for the conclusions and for taking public health action, /some of the results not synthesised into conclusion \n\n\n\n',3,'N/A-The study results with miner modification will solve actions/recommendations and control measures /\n The study was not addressing a clear public health actions and  not recommended to address the problem /In addition the study to implementing and strengthening public health surveillance systems was not recommend on conclusion for policies or legislation ',3,NULL),(184,73,134,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 06:30:57','2025-01-09 06:30:57',5,'N/A',4,'sampling technique is not clearly stated. How do they select the 600 participants, the way reached the participants is not clear. ',4,'it was better to add the CI of the percent of patients with uncontrolled hypertension in order to understand the normality of the finding and its existence with in the interval.',3,'The conclusion part includes ideas which are not presented in the result like alcohol intake,what resolve to save  life is doing currently are not part of the abstract objective. So since conclusion is expected towards addressing the objective  the last tow line of the conclusion part are not necessary. ',5,'N/A',5,NULL),(185,12,136,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 07:01:13','2025-01-09 07:01:13',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,'N/A',3,'N/A',2,NULL),(186,31,136,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 07:04:56','2025-01-09 07:04:56',3,'N/A',2,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(187,44,136,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 07:07:15','2025-01-09 07:07:15',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(188,68,136,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 07:09:28','2025-01-09 07:09:28',4,'N/A',2,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(189,73,144,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 07:11:41','2025-01-09 07:11:41',4,'The author has mentioned that HTN is a major public health problem and described the objective of the study. However, the background lacks some description of gaps or significance.',3,'Simple random sampling methods were used to select 603 study participants. However, how many hypertensive patients were registered and followed? Are the sampled participants not under follow-up?',4,'N/A',3,'The conclusion section needs to be supported by data in the result section. \"Advice to stop or minimize alcohol intake should be done\", is not supported by data in the result section. ',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(190,89,136,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 07:12:08','2025-01-09 07:12:08',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(191,106,136,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 07:15:08','2025-01-09 07:15:08',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',2,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',2,NULL),(192,94,144,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 07:26:27','2025-01-09 07:26:27',3,'N/A',2,'The overall study design is not adequately described.',2,'Methods are mixed in the result section',2,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,NULL),(193,21,145,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 07:43:35','2025-01-09 07:43:35',4,'N/A',2,'The author did not described the study design used to address the extent of outbreak. Sampling technique and study population source was not describe. Specific statistical analysis procedure should be describe instead of naming software packages. ',2,'The study result did not answer the study objectives. The study result was summarized inappropriately (for example, median was reported with standard deviation). The result was not sufficient and adequate to allow to reach at conclusion.',3,'N/A',2,'N/A',3,NULL),(194,112,144,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 07:45:01','2025-01-09 07:45:01',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'The author recommended public health actions. ',3,NULL),(195,43,145,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 08:15:15','2025-01-09 08:15:15',3,'N/A',2,'The author did not describe the study setting, sampling technique, study population, and data collection method. Source of the data was nor mentioned. ',3,'N/A',3,'The conclusion addressed the problem and objectives. However, it is not clear why the author reported that the index test uptake is low in this study whereas the prevalence was 84.1%. Is there any standard or reference for this?',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(196,13,66,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 08:17:11','2025-01-09 08:17:11',2,'N/A',2,'N/A',1,'N/A',2,'N/A',1,'N/A',2,NULL),(197,15,139,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 08:19:52','2025-01-09 08:19:52',3,'The background presents the significance of measles as a public health issue, especially in Ethiopia. However, it lacks specific antecedent data to strengthen the rationale. The study objectives are implied but not explicitly stated, which could leave readers unclear about the study\'s aims.',3,' The study design is described as a case-control study, which is appropriate for the objectives. However, critical definitions (e.g., what constitutes a case) are not explicitly stated. The methods section could benefit from more detail on the epidemiological/statistical procedures used rather than just naming software. The data sources are mentioned, but clearer descriptions would enhance understanding.',4,' Results logically follow from the methods, and key statistics are provided. The presentation of attack rates and case fatality rates is clear. However, some numerical comparisons could be better organized for clarity, and the presentation of confidence intervals could be more consistent.',4,'The conclusions are based on the data and address the study objectives. The interpretation of risk factors aligns with the findings, and the conclusions are relevant to public health. However, the synthesis could be more robust, avoiding mere repetition of data.',3,'The abstract mentions potential risk factors and implications for public health action. However, specific recommendations or actions derived directly from the results are lacking. The significance of findings in the context of existing knowledge could be better articulated.',3,NULL),(198,74,145,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 08:30:19','2025-01-09 08:30:19',2,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,'N/A',1,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,NULL),(199,93,145,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 08:50:19','2025-01-09 08:50:19',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'Despite the objective included clinical characteristics and description of surveillance data by place, they were not performed and describe in result.  ',2,'N/A',2,'N/A',4,NULL),(200,111,145,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 09:05:55','2025-01-09 09:05:55',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'The study result did not summarized the description of outbreak sufficiently. ',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(201,45,66,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 09:11:45','2025-01-09 09:11:45',4,'the public health problem is clearly stated, the significance is well articulated, and the objective is stated ',4,'N/A',5,'result aligned with scientific method, provide complete feature of the study offer valuable information for public health action',4,'better to broaden the public health implication ',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(202,58,145,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 09:12:31','2025-01-09 09:12:31',2,'The background describes more about the problem facts instead of indicating the rationale of the study and how the outbreak was notified and investigation was initiated.',1,'N/A',1,'N/A',1,'N/A',1,'N/A',1,NULL),(203,34,139,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 12:16:58','2025-01-09 12:16:58',4,' The background presents the public health issue of stunting in children and highlights the lesser-studied impact of household air pollution. The significance of the study is apparent, and the rationale is well-articulated. However, the study objectives could be stated more explicitly to enhance clarity.',4,'The methods section adequately describes the study design as a prospective cohort study, which is appropriate for the objectives. The population is clearly defined, and the exposure groups are specified. However, critical definitions (e.g., what constitutes \"solid fuel\" and \"clean fuel\") could be clearer. The statistical methods are described, but naming specific statistical tests rather than just mentioning general procedures would strengthen this section.',5,'The results logically follow the methods, with appropriate statistical measures presented. Key findings are summarized effectively, and the use of beta coefficients and confidence intervals is clear. However, some numerical comparisons could be organized better for clarity, and the presentation of results could benefit from more explicit context regarding the implications of the findings.',5,'The conclusions are well-founded on the data presented and address the study\'s objectives. The interpretation is consistent with current scientific knowledge, and the author synthesizes results into actionable conclusions. The need for public education and interventions is clearly articulated, reinforcing the relevance of the findings.',4,'The study builds on existing knowledge and addresses an immediate public health problem. The recommendations for public education and improvements in kitchen ventilation are practical and derived from study results. However, more detail on how these recommendations could be implemented or evaluated would strengthen the significance.',4,NULL),(204,55,139,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 12:27:11','2025-01-09 12:27:11',5,' The background effectively highlights the global and regional significance of HIV, emphasizing the need for surveillance. The public health problem is apparent, and the rationale for the study is well-articulated. However, while the study objectives are implied, they could be stated more explicitly to enhance clarity.',4,'The methods section describes the study design as a cross-sectional study, which is appropriate for the objectives. The population and data sources (DHIS2 and PHEM reports) are mentioned, but critical definitions (e.g., what constitutes \"key population groups\") could be clearer. The statistical methods are referenced, but naming specific statistical tests used would strengthen this section.',5,'The results logically follow from the methods, with appropriate quantitative measures presented. Key findings are summarized effectively, and the positivity rates are clearly articulated. However, some numerical comparisons could be better organized for clarity, and additional context on the implications of findings would enhance understanding.',5,'The conclusions are based on the data presented and address the study\'s objectives. The interpretation aligns with current scientific knowledge, and the need for targeted interventions is clearly articulated. However, the conclusions could benefit from a more robust synthesis of the results rather than merely summarizing the data.',4,'The study builds on existing knowledge and addresses an immediate public health problem. Recommendations for targeted interventions in urban areas and among key populations are practical and derived from the study results. More detail on how these recommendations could be implemented or evaluated would strengthen the significance.',4,NULL),(205,73,139,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 12:35:29','2025-01-09 12:35:29',5,'The background effectively highlights the public health issue of uncontrolled hypertension and its significance. The rationale for the study is clear, and the objectives are stated. However, providing some key statistics or antecedent data on hypertension in the region could enhance the context.',4,'The methods section describes the study design as a cross-sectional study, which is appropriate for the objectives. The population and sampling method are clearly stated, and the data sources (interviewer-administered questionnaire and data abstraction checklist) are specified. However, critical definitions (e.g., what constitutes \"uncontrolled hypertension\") could be more explicit. While statistical methods are mentioned, naming specific tests used in the analysis would strengthen this section.',5,'The results logically follow the methods, with appropriate quantitative measures presented. Key findings are summarized effectively, and the associations with uncontrolled hypertension are clearly articulated. However, some numerical comparisons could be better organized for clarity, and it would be helpful to provide context regarding the implications of these findings.',5,'The conclusions are based on the data presented and address the study\'s objectives. The interpretation aligns with current scientific knowledge, and the need for targeted interventions is clearly articulated. However, the conclusions could benefit from a more robust synthesis of results rather than merely summarizing the data.',5,'The study addresses an immediate public health problem and offers practical recommendations for intervention based on the findings. The proposed actions, such as implementing a patient follow-up reminder system, are relevant and derived from the results. More detail on how these recommendations could be implemented or evaluated would strengthen this section.',5,NULL),(206,92,139,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 12:41:57','2025-01-09 12:41:57',4,'The background effectively outlines the significance of HIV as a major health concern and contextualizes the impact of armed conflict on healthcare in Tigray. The objective of the study is clearly stated. However, providing specific statistics or data on HIV prevalence in the region prior to the conflict could strengthen the rationale.',4,'The methods section describes a mixed study design, which is appropriate for the objectives. The source population and sampling methods are stated, but critical definitions (e.g., what constitutes \"engaged in HIV treatment\") could be clearer. While the software packages for data analysis are mentioned, naming specific statistical tests or procedures used would improve this section.',4,'The results logically follow from the methods, with appropriate quantitative measures presented. Key findings are summarized effectively, and the statistics regarding client status post-war are clearly articulated. However, the organization of numerical data could be improved for clarity, and the implications of the findings could be better contextualized.',4,'The conclusions are based on the data presented and address the study\'s objectives. The interpretation aligns with current scientific knowledge, and the need for adjustments to the healthcare system is clearly articulated. However, the conclusions could benefit from a more comprehensive synthesis of results rather than merely summarizing the data.',5,'The study addresses an immediate public health problem and offers practical recommendations based on the findings. The proposed actions, such as adjustments to healthcare infrastructure and inquiries into drug resistance, are relevant. More detail on how these recommendations could be implemented or evaluated would strengthen this section.',4,NULL),(207,111,139,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 12:50:14','2025-01-09 12:50:14',4,'The background effectively establishes dengue fever as a significant public health threat and provides context regarding its prevalence in Ethiopia. The study\'s objective to describe the outbreak and identify associated factors is clearly stated. However, including specific data on the incidence or previous outbreaks in the region could strengthen the rationale.',4,'The methods section describes the study design adequately, mentioning both descriptive analysis and a case-control approach. The population and data sources are clear, but critical definitions (e.g., what constitutes a \"case\" or \"control\") could be more explicitly stated. While the statistical methods are mentioned, specific procedures (e.g., types of regression analysis) could be detailed further for clarity.',5,'The results logically follow from the methods, with key findings summarized effectively. The data is presented clearly, including attack rates and demographic breakdowns. However, the organization of numerical data could be improved for better readability, and it would be beneficial to contextualize the findings with respect to the broader implications for public health.',4,'The conclusions are based on the data presented and directly address the study\'s objectives. The interpretation aligns well with current scientific knowledge, and the identified risk factors are relevant. However, the conclusions could benefit from a more integrated synthesis of the results rather than merely listing findings.',4,'The study addresses an immediate public health issue and offers practical recommendations based on the results. The proposed actions to reduce breeding sites and strengthen surveillance are relevant and actionable. More detail on how these recommendations could be implemented or evaluated would enhance this section.',4,NULL),(208,15,12,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 14:09:06','2025-01-09 14:09:06',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(209,32,12,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 14:10:30','2025-01-09 14:10:30',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(210,52,12,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 14:13:43','2025-01-09 14:13:43',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(211,66,12,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 14:14:50','2025-01-09 14:14:50',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(212,85,12,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 14:15:58','2025-01-09 14:15:58',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(213,104,12,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 14:17:25','2025-01-09 14:17:25',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(214,69,66,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 14:22:56','2025-01-09 14:22:56',3,'the background doesn\'t highlight knowledge and burden gap',4,'Clear statistical presentation and appropriate use of statistical model and numerical comparison',4,'Discuss missing data and limitation of the study to enhance transparency',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(215,68,174,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 19:35:02','2025-01-09 19:35:02',4,'N/A-The study was significance and addressing the public health problem and also key antecedent data or issues presented to set the stage for the study/but the  author not  explicitly state the study objective(s)',3,'N/A-The study design was adequate described and appropriate and efficient to address the study objectives and the  study design was not critical definitions clearly stated also the epidemiological/statistical methods concisely described and the Authors was name specific epidemiological or statistical procedures instead of naming software packages. ',4,'N/A-The study results logically follow the described methods and also the study results summarized using appropriate quantitative/qualitative measures/ The results numerical comparisons correct and appropriate and also sufficient',4,'- The conclusion and interpretation based on the data presented and address the problem and objectives/The study was sufficiently valid and reliable to serve as a basis for the conclusions and for taking public health action/The interpretation of the findings consistent with current scientific knowledge also the author synthesise results into a conclusion/Conclusions not repeat numerical data from the results .',3,'N-An immediate problems solved miner modification/Study results will recommend to take immediate actions, The study initiating or enhancing prevention or other public health programs',4,NULL),(216,88,174,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-09 20:26:17','2025-01-09 20:26:17',4,'N/A The Auter address the public health problem or question, also Key antecedent data or issues were presented /Objective of the study was addressed /type of standard study questioner was not stated/addressing appropriate study question ',4,'N/A-Study design adequately described and appropriate and efficient to address the study objective. /only Surveillance  clearly defined / Epidemiological statistical methods described/ the data source (questionnaire, registry, surveillance data set) stated',3,'N/A-The study results logically follow as described methods/ Are study results summarized using appropriate quantitative, but attributes was not clearly stated need to be clarify, data not adequate sufficient and not representative to allow the reader to reach conclusion ',3,'N/A-The conclusion and interpretation were based on the data presented but not clear/ The conclusion/interpretation not well address the problem and objectives /data not repeated on conclusion ',3,'N/A-The data not solve the immediate problem, attributes not well defined simply stated without any result description, so not ready for public health action and not strengthen the public health system',2,NULL),(217,93,140,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 08:51:24','2025-01-10 08:51:24',3,'First, I would like to say thank you for adding my comment on this abstract. As comments, the authors clearly stated the problems, indicated the important and the objective of the study  appropriately to address the problem.',2,'The study design is appropriate and efficient to address the study objective. But the statistical method and procedures to conduct this study is not clearly stated, described and strong. ',3,'The study results follow the method described and are summarized using appropriate quantitative measures. However the data presentation is not sufficient and adequate to allow the readers to reach a conclusion.',3,'Even though the conclusion and interpretation of this abstract is based on the data presented, the conclusion, interpretation, recommendation part is not sufficient. The study is not valid and reliable to serve as a basis for conclusion to take the public health action. ',3,'The actions, and recommendations are not sufficient initiating or enhancing prevention or other public health programs; developing procedures, policies or legislation; implementing and strengthening public health surveillance systems; reducing disease incidence to address the public health problem.',3,NULL),(218,106,174,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 09:39:41','2025-01-10 09:39:41',4,'N/A-Auter address the public health problem or question, and it is significant / the author explicitly state the study objective and the study is appropriate for addressing the problem or study question?',5,'N/A-The overall study design adequately described and also the study design is appropriate and efficient to address the study objectives/ data source stated/ Auter clearly describe statistical methods concisely ',5,'N/A- The study results summarized using appropriate quantitative/qualitative measures/The study results logically follow the described methods/data presented were sufficient and adequate  to allow the reader to reach a conclusion.',4,'N/A-The conclusion and interpretation were based on the data presented and also address the problem and objectives/The study appear sufficiently valid and reliable to serve as a basis for the conclusions and for taking public health action/The result part not repeated in conclusion',4,'N/A-The data solve an immediate problem or build on existing knowledge/ Based on the study results recommendation control measures if action taken it will be practical in addition Surveillance system will be strengthen.',5,NULL),(219,21,148,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 09:39:45','2025-01-10 09:39:45',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',3,'The result is very shallow and unfortunately, it didn\'t come up with something peculiar. The findings are kind of repetition of the known facts about anthrax. The Confidence Intervals are very wide and inconclusive. The control measures were not even described. ',4,'N/A',3,'Investigating such an outbreak is undoubtedly of public health importance; however, the information provided in this abstract is somewhat superficial. It lacks essential details about the index case, the duration of the outbreak, and the control measures implemented.',3,NULL),(220,21,148,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 09:41:58','2025-01-10 09:41:58',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(221,34,174,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 09:58:04','2025-01-10 09:58:04',2,'N/A-Not clearly address the public health problem and not significant/key antecedent data or issues not presented to set the stage for the study/ The author not explicitly state the study objective(s)and not  appropriate for addressing the problem or study question',2,'N/A-The study design not clearly, adequately described/The epidemiological/statistical method snot  concisely described/in general the method part is not clear need to re organized and specific',2,'N/A-Result part similarly as method need re arrange and specific not clear for readers to understand',3,'N/A-Need to rewrite and specific ',2,'N/A-In general has no public significance and not SMART',2,NULL),(222,41,148,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 09:59:20','2025-01-10 09:59:20',3,'The background contains excessive and unnecessary details about measles.',2,'Unnecessary details, such as the distance of the study area from the capital and the full case definitions for cases and controls, can be omitted. Instead, important information, such as the number of cases and controls included and the duration of the outbreak, should have been clearly described.',2,'The report completely lacks descriptive findings and instead directly lists the identified factors. Overall, it is very superficial, omitting crucial details such as the duration of the outbreak, a description of the index case, and the control measures implemented.',2,'It merely repeats the findings and fails to provide any recommendations',2,'Investigating measles outbreak definitely has a public health importance. However, this abstract fails to convey that significance, as it lacks essential details.',2,NULL),(223,59,148,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 10:29:08','2025-01-10 10:29:08',3,'The background contains unnecessary details about drought. It would have been good it the author directly indicate the local problem and give much attention to the findings. ',3,'A semi-structured questionnaire is typically used for qualitative studies. However, it is unclear what type of data was collected, from how many participants, and which analysis technique was employed.',3,'It would be better to explicitly mention the actual numbers rather than using vague terms like \'low vaccination coverage.\' Additionally, abbreviations should be avoided in both the abstract and the title. However, the actual numbers provided are not particularly informative regarding the drought situation as it doesn\'t consider the total population. ',3,'It lacks recommendation ',3,'It holds public health significance, as the investigation identified several challenges that require immediate intervention. However, it lacks clarity and scientific consistency in the information presented',3,NULL),(224,75,148,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 11:37:48','2025-01-10 11:37:48',3,'There is method section under the background and there is repetition of ideas in the method subsection which is already mentioned above.  ',4,'But there is repetitions  ',4,'The AOR lacks confidence interval. ',3,'The conclusion and recommendations are based on the findings, but the sentences need to be rephrased for better readability',4,'The findings have public health significance, revealing a gap that underscores the need for awareness programs about rabies.',4,NULL),(225,95,148,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 11:51:31','2025-01-10 11:51:31',4,'N/A',4,'The term \'randomly selected\' seems questionable. Additionally, it is unclear why the study was conducted in September, given that the outbreak was reported on July 13, resulting in a one and half month gap',5,' Both descriptive and analytical findings were presented adequately; however, the control measures implemennted were not mentioned.',5,'The conclusion and recommendations are based on the findings',4,'It holds some public health importance, even though the study did not identify any new risk factors for the malaria outbreak.',5,NULL),(226,113,148,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 12:15:07','2025-01-10 12:15:07',3,'Some unnecessary descriptions could be reduced\n',4,'It would have been helpful to include details on how the cases and controls were selected. Specifically, the case definition for cutaneous leishmaniasis and the process for identifying controls should be provided, rather than focusing on additional details about the selection of variables for the model',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,NULL),(227,27,157,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 14:25:32','2025-01-10 14:25:32',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,NULL),(228,40,157,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 14:31:37','2025-01-10 14:31:37',4,'N/A',2,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(229,61,157,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 14:39:26','2025-01-10 14:39:26',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(230,80,157,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 14:52:28','2025-01-10 14:52:28',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(231,97,157,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 15:00:02','2025-01-10 15:00:02',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(232,41,153,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 16:53:41','2025-01-10 16:53:41',2,'The population under study is not indicated in the title; however, it focuses on under 5 children and pregnant women in the background. The need for determining the magnitude should not not be the objective of this particular study; it is case control study \nThe gap for factors is not also justified!',3,'The sample size issue is not included, and which logistic regression method is used is not also mentioned.',4,'The direction of association is not appropriately presented.',4,'Result for respondents who know about measles mode of transmission is not included in the conclusion.',3,'Measles is among the common infectious disease though multiple efforts are taken in Ethiopia. ',3,NULL),(233,58,153,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 17:09:03','2025-01-10 17:09:03',3,'The gap (the reason to conduct this study) is not indicated.',2,' The sample size data collection statistical analysis method  used to identify the factors is not described.',2,'the results are not presented with respect to the outbreak investigation,\nthere is no any result that shows statistical significance.',2,'the conclusion is not based on comparison with references.\nit is not also directly based on the study results',3,'it is among the common infectious diseases in the country',2,NULL),(234,78,153,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 17:25:17','2025-01-10 17:25:17',4,'it is to the point and brief',3,'the sample size is not described.\nquicker  blood pressure control and its time are not defined (the event and the time).',3,'The sentence  stating (In contrast, factors leading to delayed BP control included age ≥ 60 years (AHR = 0.378, 95% CI: 0.236–0.605), stage II hypertension (AHR = 0.626, 95% CI: 0.467–0.839), elevated creatinine (≥ 1.5 mg/dL; AHR = 0.371, 95% CI: 0.173–0.799), and fasting blood sugar (FBS) ≥ 126 mg/dL; AHR = 0.335, 95% CI: 0.152–0.738)) is not approprately presented.',4,'it is relatively good, but it still needs keeping the problem under study in study and being consistent.',4,'Timely blood pressure control is among the priority solutions for HTN patients.',4,NULL),(235,97,153,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 17:36:18','2025-01-10 17:36:18',4,'good, though it lacks clear indication of the gap',4,'the sampling technique for both cases and controls is not described',2,'the results of binary logistic regression for appropriate measures of association/effect is not presented',3,'it is good, but the results to be concluded are not described',3,'it is among the public health challenges',3,NULL),(236,115,153,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 17:49:29','2025-01-10 17:49:29',3,'the gap still needs more evidence',4,'it is described, but will be better if adequate literatures are reviewed. Or the method used to control confounders is checked.\nB/C most of the significant factors are expected to have correlation.',3,'it is good to focus on the objective, Extra descriptive results may sometimes mislead.',3,'the awareness creation is not the direct finding of the study',3,'it is among the common infectious diseases of public health importance.',3,NULL),(237,113,140,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 19:00:29','2025-01-10 19:00:29',4,'I would like to thank you for providing this chance to review this abstract. Following the revision of this abstract in detail, the authors state the objective of the study.',3,'The study design is appropriate to address the study objective. The statistical methods and procedures are clearly described; however, the critical definitions are not clearly stated. ',4,'The study results follow the method described and are summarized using appropriate quantitative measures and presented in a sufficient manner.',3,'The conclusion and interpretation of this abstract is not in detail to address the problems and objectives of the study and are not also valid and reliable to serve as a base for public health actions.',3,'The authors provided recommendations. But the recommendations are not based on the findings derived directly from their study results. In genera there is a limitation on the recommendations part.',3,NULL),(238,29,122,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 19:11:02','2025-01-10 19:11:02',4,'Key antecedent issues are presented to set the stage and objectives are presented',4,'Study design is described, the population is apparent and data source is mentioned',5,'Results follow the described methods and are summarized using appropriate quantitative measures ',5,'Conclusion is based on the data presented and results are synthesized into a conclusion ',4,'Data build on existing knowledge and recommendations are practical. The recommendations are likely to address the problem ',5,NULL),(239,50,122,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-10 19:28:28','2025-01-10 19:28:28',4,'The public health problem is apparent, and the objectives are described',4,'N/A',5,'Results presented following the logical flow of the methods and are summarized using appropriate quantitative methods',5,'N/A',4,'The study showed the gaps in case detection by geography and the challenges behind the suboptimal case detection',5,NULL),(240,64,122,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-11 03:48:43','2025-01-11 03:48:43',4,'The public health problem is well described, and the objectives are mentioned clearly ',4,'The study design is well described and appropriate for the objective. The data source is also mentioned ',3,'The results presentation lacks clarity, the strengths and weaknesses are not presented in a logical flow and mixed sometimes. ',3,'The conclusion is not in line with the results. Though the study mentioned the limitations of the preparedness, surveillance and response, the conclusion says it was an effective PH response ',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(241,83,122,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-11 04:08:35','2025-01-11 04:08:35',4,'The public health problem is apparent, and the objectives are mentioned clearly ',3,'The method is not described adequately; lacks details how controls are selected and what variables are considered as isk factors for the analysis and others. The definition for Measels outbreak is not given ',4,'The results follow the logical flow of the methods and are summarized using appropriate quantitative methods  ',2,'The conclusion is not in line with the result presented. Delays in case detection is not the reason for the outbreak but is the reason for not controlling the outbreak early and was not mentioned in the results. The recommendations are not addressing the problems identified ',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(242,102,122,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-11 04:39:18','2025-01-11 04:39:18',2,'The background is poorly written and didn\'t set the stage for the study and the objectives are not clearly documented ',3,'The method is not clearly stated and confusing, nothing is mentioned how controls are selected ',2,'The results are not presented clearly and difficult to understand ',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',2,NULL),(243,29,171,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-11 07:03:00','2025-01-11 07:03:00',5,'N/A',3,'the author mentioned they used ArcGIS software which is used for spatial analysis, but in the result section nothing mentioned regarding geographic distribution of Malaria',3,'there is some inconsistency between methods and results ',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(244,48,171,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-11 07:17:35','2025-01-11 07:17:35',4,'N/A',3,'rather than conducting descriptive analysis only it is better if the author applied advanced analysis like identifying factors associated with malnutrition. In addition treatment outcome is one of the objective but not summarized in abstracts.',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,NULL),(245,65,171,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-11 07:43:05','2025-01-11 07:43:05',5,'N/A',3,'for Generalized structural equation modeling there is no applicable goodness of fit statistics, the author mentioned AIC and BIC as goodness of fit statistics which is wrong, AIC and BIC are rather used for model selection or comparison.',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(246,85,171,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-11 07:49:26','2025-01-11 07:49:26',4,'N/A',3,'When assessing trend of such disease of public health importance better to include forecasting which is not addressed here.',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,NULL),(247,103,171,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-11 07:59:49','2025-01-11 07:59:49',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'there is previous article on the same topic and this paper seems replication of the same research which is not totally bad in context of different settings but new things added were not clearly justified',5,NULL),(248,26,162,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-11 10:39:16','2025-01-11 10:39:16',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,NULL),(249,45,162,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-11 11:21:26','2025-01-11 11:21:26',3,'N/A',3,'The design, \"repeated cross sectional\" may not be appropriate choice, or wrongly specified. The abstract lacks important definitions and better to clarify the following concepts. For example, does the diabetes case were new or not? What were the data specifically extracted from the monthly report, NCD surveillance report and DHIS2? In addition, better to mention the specific time series analysis method, if done. While the author(s) mention \"lack of data on DM incidence\" as a acknowledge gap, the method and result section does not address the incidence.',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(250,63,162,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-11 12:23:42','2025-01-11 12:23:42',2,'The author(s) assessed NTD\'s burden, and NTD\'s are important public health problem. Although the study aims to compare the NTD\'s burden in \"rural and urban slum settings\", the definition for rural slum in the Ethiopian context is confusing. Because the sparse settlement of the population in the rural Ethiopia, the definition of rural slum is confusion. In addition, the method section does not mention about the definition of rural slum and its selection procedure. Most importantly, the significance and justifications for the need of comparative study between the so-called rural slum and urban slum, is not clear.',4,'N/A',2,'Some of the findings may be difficult to believe. example, how \"presence of flies in the child feces\" assessed in the study. Also, it is a common practice in children to play with soil in urban and rural Ethiopian context. without controlling important confounders and without validated data collection instrument, it is highly likely for the parameters estimate to be biased. ',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(251,82,162,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-11 13:23:54','2025-01-11 13:23:54',4,'Better to move the second sentence of background section and present it before the objective. ',3,'Major issue: What does it mean salt intake reduction? most importantly the author(s) should provide sufficient and clear operational definition for \"salt intake reduction\". \n-Factors associated with salt intake reduction listed in the result section \"not advised about salt reduction\" and \"not know the daily recommended salt intake\". Is it appropriate to ask about salt intake reduction for a person who do not know about the issue. May be assessing salt intake is more relevant than salt intake reduction or provide sufficient description of its definition to improve clarity of measurements used in the study.\n-Four out of the six sentences in the method section describes about data analysis issues. please remove irrelevant details of the analysis method.    ',4,'In Ethiopia, it is not common to prepare separate dishes for each household members. In most cases household members eat from communal food. Therefore, the significant difference in salt intake reduction between male and female may be confounded by another factor. ',3,'Most of the sentences in the conclusion are repetition of the results.',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(252,102,162,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-11 13:46:40','2025-01-11 13:46:40',3,'The study objective is not stated in background section.',3,'The method lacks operational definition for cases and controls. Who were the cases? and who were the controls? How they were identified? without answering these questions, any findings from this study suggest invalid conclusion. ',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',2,'N/A',4,NULL),(253,117,162,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-11 14:01:06','2025-01-11 14:01:06',4,'N/A',2,'-The study design mentioned in the method section \"descriptive study\" is not appropriate design to answer the study objective. \n-The abstract does not provide analysis method.  ',2,'N/A',2,'The conclusion was not based on the result. ',2,'N/A',4,NULL),(254,77,156,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-12 12:39:48','2025-01-12 12:39:48',4,'N/A',4,'The randomness of the health facilities selection is not clear. We are not sure that there are more than four health centers in that woreda. The data collection tool needs to have parts of observations, and document review that would compliment the interview.',3,'How the investigator determines whether the preparedness is 80% is unclear.  ',4,'Should be in line with the result.',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(255,96,156,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-12 12:58:05','2025-01-12 12:58:05',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'Some of the variables like formal education, median wealth, and co-morbidity need to be clear for reader. It is not clear whether it is talking about the absence or presence of these variables.',4,'Partly clear, but the last sentence of the section is vague.',5,'N/A',5,NULL),(256,117,156,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-12 13:12:48','2025-01-12 13:12:48',4,'Investigators cannot identify risk factors by descriptive study.',4,'Even though, descriptive analysis is important for outbreak investigation, it is not a complete methodology to establish the identification of risk factors. ',4,'Some of the presentations are not clear. For example, the investigator said the attack rate is high among males which is 0.06, but does not indicate the number of male participants. and also the same for age group presentation.',2,'What was written in the conclusion does not relate to the result presented.',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(257,28,158,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-12 14:43:25','2025-01-12 14:43:25',4,' She does not explain or presented to set the stage for the study',5,'N/A',4,'The result parts had not include numerical comparisons ',4,'The conclusion did not explain the results unlikely to be attributable to chance, confounding, or other potential biases.',5,'N/A',5,NULL),(258,41,158,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-12 16:11:07','2025-01-12 16:11:07',5,'N/A',4,'It not explain epidemiological link and also states only soft ware name instead of procedure statistical',3,'There is no comparison from others and the finding in the results  is not include time and person',4,'Not presented measles the magnitude in conclusion or result parts',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(259,62,158,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-12 18:31:51','2025-01-12 18:31:51',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'not clearly presented prevention methods or other public health programs',5,NULL),(260,81,158,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-12 19:07:04','2025-01-12 19:07:04',5,'N/A',4,'The Authors did not clearly explain study design either community or facility based in addition to do not show statical packages of procedure ',4,'The result parts had not comparison and time bound ',4,'Conclusions is very short  and repeated from the results or restate them with adjectives replacing numbers',5,'N/A',4,NULL),(261,35,175,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-12 19:25:46','2025-01-12 19:25:46',4,'It effectively highlights childhood multi-morbidity as a significant global health concern, particularly in low-income settings. While the abstract provides some context, it could benefit from additional details about the broader implications of childhood multimorbidity and household air pollution on healthcare systems and socioeconomic factors. This would enhance the significance of the problem.',4,'It effectively communicates essential aspects of the design and methodology while leaving room for minor improvements in detail and clarity. While the it does not explicitly define terms like \"multimorbidity\" or \"household air pollution,\" these concepts are generally understood in public health contexts. However, providing definitions could enhance clarity, especially for broader audiences who may not be familiar with these terms.',5,'The results logically follow from the methods, are summarized using appropriate quantitative measures, and provide sufficient data for readers to reach informed conclusions about the study\'s findings. Minor improvements could include more context around how these findings relate to existing literature, But overall, the presentation is strong and effective',5,'The conclusions are well-supported by the data, address the study objectives effectively, and demonstrate sufficient validity and reliability to inform public health action. Minor enhancements could include more broader implications for public health policy, but overall, the conclusions are strong and actionable.',4,' The research effectively addresses an immediate public health problem while building on existing knowledge. The recommendations are practical and derived from study results, with a strong likelihood of addressing the identified health issues if implemented. Minor improvements could include providing evidence of any ongoing public health actions based on these findings or further detailing how proposed policies might be enacted.',5,NULL),(262,99,158,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-12 19:27:44','2025-01-12 19:27:44',5,'N/A',4,'He did not talk about the data sources of the study ',5,'N/A',5,'N/A',4,'He did not shown public health actions recommended or completed',5,NULL),(263,51,175,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-12 19:44:47','2025-01-12 19:44:47',3,'The background and rationale section provides a foundational understanding of the public health issue at hand but requires refinement to enhance clarity and depth. Strengthening these aspects will improve the overall quality and impact of the abstract, making it more compelling for readers and stakeholders in public health.',3,'The methods section provides a foundational understanding of how the study was conducted but requires additional detail to enhance clarity and rigor. By explicitly defining key terms, detailing statistical analyses, and clarifying the population and data collection processes, this section could significantly improve its effectiveness in supporting the study\'s objectives.',4,'The presentation of results is strong, with logical coherence and appropriate quantitative measures that effectively summarize key findings. While sufficient data are provided for readers to draw conclusions, adding contextual interpretation and considering visual representations could further enhance clarity and impact. Overall, this section successfully communicates critical information about malaria trends in Northwest Ethiopia.',4,'The conclusions and interpretations are grounded in the data presented but could benefit from greater clarity and depth. Strengthening connections between findings and their implications for public health practice, addressing potential biases, and providing actionable recommendations would enhance the overall impact of this section. Overall, while informative, there is room for improvement in synthesizing results into a comprehensive conclusion that guides future action.',4,'The public health significance of this study is strong, as it addresses an urgent issue while building on existing knowledge about malaria trends in Ethiopia. While practical recommendations are made, providing more specific actions and context regarding their implementation would enhance the overall impact. Overall, this work has the potential to inform effective public health interventions and contribute meaningfully to ongoing efforts to combat malaria in the region.',4,NULL),(264,69,175,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-12 20:33:27','2025-01-12 20:33:27',4,'It is strong in articulating the significance of the public health problem and stating clear objectives but could benefit from additional context through key data or references to prior research.',3,'While it adequately describes the overall study design and population involved, it falls short in providing necessary definitions, detailed statistical methods, and clarity regarding data sources. Addressing these areas would significantly strengthen the methods section.',4,'The results are clearly presented and logically follow from the methods, with appropriate quantitative measures and comparisons. Minor improvements could be made by including additional demographic or clinical details to provide further context for the findings.',4,'The conclusions are strong, data-driven, and relevant; however, a more explicit discussion regarding potential biases or limitations could enhance transparency and strengthen confidence in the findings.\n',4,'The study effectively addresses a pressing public health problem and provides actionable recommendations derived from its results. However, more information about the implementation status of these recommendations would further enhance its significance.',4,NULL),(265,89,175,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-12 20:50:49','2025-01-12 20:50:49',4,'It successfully communicates the public health problem and objectives but could benefit from additional contextual data to enhance understanding and urgency.',4,'The study design is appropriate and well-described, but minor improvements in clarity regarding definitions and statistical methods could enhance its overall quality.',4,'The results are clearly presented, logically follow from the methods, and provide adequate data for drawing conclusions. Minor improvements could be made by including brief interpretations or implications of the findings to enhance clarity further.',4,'The conclusions are strong, data-driven, and relevant; however, a more explicit discussion regarding potential biases or limitations could enhance transparency and strengthen confidence in the findings.\n',5,'The study effectively addresses a pressing public health problem with actionable recommendations derived from its findings.',4,NULL),(266,107,175,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-12 21:09:39','2025-01-12 21:09:39',4,'The background and rationale effectively establish the context for the study, highlighting the significance of gastrointestinal infections as a public health concern and clearly stating its objectives. While it provides a solid foundation for understanding why this research is necessary, incorporating more detailed antecedent data could further enhance its impact.',4,'The methods section provides a solid overview of the study design, population, and statistical analysis. It effectively outlines how the study aims to identify prevalence and associated factors related to gastrointestinal pathogens among food handlers. However, some areas could benefit from additional clarity regarding definitions and specific statistical methods.',4,'The results section is well-structured and effectively communicates key findings in a logical manner. It uses appropriate quantitative measures and provides sufficient data for drawing conclusions about the prevalence and antimicrobial resistance associated with gastrointestinal pathogens among food handlers.',5,'The conclusions and interpretations presented in the abstract are well-founded, logically derived from the data, and relevant to public health action. They effectively summarize key findings while addressing the study\'s objectives.',5,'\nThe study presents a significant contribution to public health by identifying key factors related to foodborne pathogen prevalence among food handlers and providing actionable recommendations for intervention. It builds on existing knowledge while addressing immediate public health concerns.',5,NULL),(267,16,20,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-12 23:32:21','2025-01-12 23:32:21',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,NULL),(268,29,20,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-12 23:42:19','2025-01-12 23:42:19',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(269,44,20,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-12 23:56:30','2025-01-12 23:56:30',3,'N/A',2,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(270,67,20,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-13 00:04:58','2025-01-13 00:04:58',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(271,84,20,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-13 07:29:53','2025-01-13 07:29:53',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,NULL),(272,87,66,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-13 07:46:48','2025-01-13 07:46:48',3,'the public health problem did not mentioned well ',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(273,104,20,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-13 07:47:38','2025-01-13 07:47:38',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,NULL),(274,105,66,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-13 08:04:40','2025-01-13 08:04:40',5,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'it will be better if he mentioned number of recurrences in addition to the incidence rate.                             \nobserved good medication adherence?? ',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(275,25,166,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-14 17:47:40','2025-01-14 17:47:40',4,'While the background sets the stage effectively, providing more context on historical trends of malaria outbreaks in this district or comparisons with similar regions would enhance clarity on the significance of the investigation.',3,'The abstract would benefit from explicitly stating the case definitions and clarifying principal exposures. Providing a rationale for the selection of the 1km radius and active search approach would also strengthen the design description.',4,'Clarifying the sample size for the control group and providing further breakdown by time or place could improve the understanding of trends. Ensure that comparisons between subgroups are statistically validated.',3,'The conclusions synthesize findings effectively but could further elaborate on the implications for future preventive measures or surveillance systems to prevent similar outbreaks. ',4,' Including details about whether initial response efforts were completed or their outcomes would enhance the practical relevance of the recommendations. Future prevention strategies should also be elaborated',4,NULL),(276,48,166,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-14 17:56:08','2025-01-14 17:56:08',4,'The study clearly identifies the critical health problem of severe acute malnutrition among children under five in Tigray, Ethiopia. The background effectively highlights the importance of the issue, supported by relevant contextual information. However, the objective could be more explicitly defined beyond analyzing trends, screening, and treatment outcomes, such as specifying the intended health intervention outcomes or policy recommendations.',4,'The secondary data analysis approach is appropriate for evaluating historical trends and outcomes. However, while descriptive statistical methods such as proportions, rates, and ratios are mentioned, no specific mention of inferential statistical techniques or detailed epidemiological methods is provided. Critical definitions like \"severe acute malnutrition\" and \"screening coverage\" are implied but should be explicitly stated. The study could improve by specifying inclusion/exclusion criteria and clarifying analytical tools beyond just naming software packages.',5,'The results logically follow the stated methods and are summarized effectively using appropriate quantitative measures. Numerical comparisons are clear, and major findings, including trends in malnutrition rates, recovery rates, and geographical disparities, are well presented. The data presentation is adequate for drawing meaningful conclusions, though more detailed subgroup analysis could strengthen the interpretation of findings.',4,'The conclusions are consistent with the presented data and address key public health concerns. They highlight critical gaps in screening coverage and disparities requiring targeted interventions. However, the conclusion could improve by more comprehensively synthesizing key findings into actionable insights, rather than restating results. Recommendations should provide more detailed strategies for addressing identified gaps.',4,'Recommendations for healthcare access improvement and community-based interventions are practical and derived from study results. However, the abstract does not report any already undertaken or completed public health actions. Including specific examples of proposed or ongoing initiatives would better demonstrate the study\'s contribution to public health solutions.',4,NULL),(277,65,166,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-14 18:04:34','2025-01-14 18:04:34',5,'The abstract clearly presents the public health problem: high prevalence of stunting and wasting in newborns and the importance of maternal dietary practices during pregnancy. The significance is well articulated, emphasizing the critical window of the first 1,000 days for child growth and development. The objectives are explicitly stated and are appropriate for addressing the research question.',4,'The study design—a prospective cohort study—is appropriate for investigating dietary influences on newborn nutritional outcomes. Methods, such as the use of PCF analysis, generalized structural equation modeling, and assessment tools for dietary practices, are adequately described. However, critical definitions (e.g., \"inadequate dietary practices,\" \"stunting,\" \"wasting\") could be more clearly defined. Epidemiological methods are specified, but brief explanations of the criteria for inclusion in path analysis or the goodness-of-fit assessment would enhance clarity.',4,'The results are logically derived from the methods and are summarized with relevant quantitative measures, such as adjusted relative risks (ARR) and confidence intervals. Adequate data on stunting and wasting prevalence are presented to allow readers to draw conclusions. However, more clarity on how outcomes were categorized and possible subgroup analyses would improve the comprehensiveness of the results.',4,'The conclusions are based on the data presented and address the stated research problem. They provide meaningful insights into predictors of stunting and wasting at birth. The conclusions synthesize results effectively without simply repeating data. However, interpretation could better integrate current scientific knowledge and discuss how findings align with or challenge existing literature.',4,'While significant predictors are identified, actionable recommendations or control measures for improving maternal dietary practices are not clearly stated. There is limited information on whether the findings have influenced or are likely to impact public health policies or programs. Practical recommendations derived directly from the study results would strengthen this section.',4,NULL),(278,80,166,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-14 18:19:09','2025-01-14 18:19:09',4,'The abstract clearly identifies the public health issue—the mpox outbreak in Ethiopia—and emphasizes the need for emergency preparedness and public awareness. The background context is well-explained, setting the stage for the study. The significance is highlighted by citing case numbers and mortality rates in other African countries. However, the objective could be more explicitly stated. While implied in the context, a succinct statement such as \"To assess public awareness, emergency preparedness, and response readiness for mpox in Ethiopia\" would enhance clarity.',4,'The study employs a mixed-methods approach, including surveys, interviews, and secondary data analysis. The use of a scorecard model for evaluating preparedness is appropriate. Simple random sampling is mentioned, and the population involved is defined. On the other hand, descriptions of critical definitions, such as what qualifies as \"emergency preparedness,\" \"public awareness,\" or \"case definitions,\" are missing or unclear. Statistical methods are mentioned only vaguely as \"scientifically conducted\" without specifying models or statistical tests. More details on data sources (e.g., survey questionnaires or health registries) would improve transparency.',4,'Results logically follow the described methods and are summarized with appropriate qualitative and quantitative measures. The data include critical statistics about mpox cases and deaths across different regions and the survey findings about public awareness in Ethiopia.',4,'The interpretation could better integrate scientific evidence and more robust synthesis of findings instead of reiterating results. A stronger link between findings and recommended public health actions would improve its persuasiveness.',4,'Recommendations could be expanded to detail specific strategies for public education or health system strengthening. Potential long-term policy measures and international collaboration could be discussed.',4,NULL),(279,100,166,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-14 18:29:56','2025-01-14 18:29:56',4,'The public health problem of intimate partner violence (IPV) during pregnancy in Ethiopia is clearly stated, highlighting its significance. The authors explicitly state the objective of the study, which is to evaluate the effectiveness of Couple-Based Violence Prevention Education (CBVPE) in reducing IPV. This objective is appropriate and directly addresses the identified problem.',4,'The study design is adequately described as a cluster randomized controlled trial with a two-arm parallel group. It is appropriate for the objectives, effectively allowing comparison between intervention and control groups. Critical definitions, such as IPV, are implied but could benefit from clearer articulation. In addition, The epidemiological and statistical methods are mentioned (difference-in-difference analysis and GEE model), but specific details about these methods could be more concisely described. The population is stated, but the data source could be specified more clearly (e.g., type of questionnaire or data collection method).',4,'The results logically follow the methods described and are summarized with appropriate quantitative measures. The numerical comparisons appear correct, and sufficient data is presented to support conclusions. More detail on the statistical significance of findings could enhance clarity.',4,'The conclusions are based on the presented data and address the study\'s objectives. The interpretation aligns with current scientific knowledge, and the authors synthesize results well. There is a minor risk that some conclusions could be seen as overly general without sufficient context regarding limitations.',4,'The study builds on existing knowledge and offers practical recommendations for scaling up the intervention. The suggested public health actions are relevant and likely to address the identified issues, although there could be more detail on how these recommendations will be implemented.',4,NULL),(280,22,155,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-15 22:23:57','2025-01-15 22:23:57',3,'Address the local context than the global. ',4,'N/A',3,'The descriptive findings are not inline with the study design ',3,'Make specific recommendation based on the findings than general. ',3,'N/A',4,NULL),(281,38,155,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-15 22:34:39','2025-01-15 22:34:39',2,'The rationality is not inline with the research question. ',2,'uncontrolled HTN measurement is not well defined based. The study population is not addressed well.  ',3,'95 % CI for AOR is missed ',3,'lacks interpretation ',3,'N/A',2,NULL),(282,54,155,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-15 22:40:59','2025-01-15 22:40:59',4,'N/A',2,'shallow methods. The sample and how sampling is not addressed. The data analysis methods were not stated. ',3,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,NULL),(283,60,155,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-15 22:46:46','2025-01-15 22:46:46',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,'N/A',3,'N/A',4,'N/A',4,NULL),(284,116,155,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-15 22:50:56','2025-01-15 22:50:56',2,'N/A',2,NULL,2,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,'N/A',2,NULL),(285,116,155,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-15 22:55:27','2025-01-15 22:55:27',2,'N/A',3,'The detailed methods missed ',3,'N/A',2,NULL,2,'N/A',1,NULL),(286,76,155,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-16 06:05:59','2025-01-16 06:05:59',3,NULL,3,'Mixed methods requires a qualitative and quantitative approach. How the literature search was performed is essential component of the methods, however the authors not addressed.  ',3,'N/A',3,'Concluding ideas related to terrorisms is not supported with data. ',3,'N/A',3,NULL),(287,95,155,'submitted',NULL,'2025-01-16 06:13:58','2025-01-16 06:13:58',4,'N/A',3,'To confirm the presence of outbreak case control is not appropriate. Following the outbreak investigation process is essential to address the research question. ',3,'Not address all the primary research question ',3,'The research question is not addressed well  ',4,'N/A',4,NULL);

--
-- Table structure for table `role_has_permissions`
--

CREATE TABLE `role_has_permissions` (
  `permission_id` bigint unsigned NOT NULL,
  `role_id` bigint unsigned NOT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`permission_id`,`role_id`),
  KEY `role_has_permissions_role_id_foreign` (`role_id`),
  CONSTRAINT `role_has_permissions_permission_id_foreign` FOREIGN KEY (`permission_id`) REFERENCES `permissions` (`id`) ON DELETE CASCADE,
  CONSTRAINT `role_has_permissions_role_id_foreign` FOREIGN KEY (`role_id`) REFERENCES `roles` (`id`) ON DELETE CASCADE
) ENGINE=InnoDB DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci;

--
-- Dumping data for table `role_has_permissions`
--

INSERT INTO `role_has_permissions` VALUES (1,1),(2,1),(3,1),(4,1),(5,1),(6,1),(7,1),(8,1),(9,1),(10,1),(11,1),(12,1),(13,1),(14,1),(15,1),(16,1),(17,1),(18,1),(19,1),(20,1),(21,1),(22,1),(23,1),(24,1),(25,1),(26,1),(27,1),(28,1),(29,1),(30,1),(31,1),(32,1),(33,1),(34,1),(35,1),(36,1),(37,1),(38,1),(39,1),(40,1),(41,1),(42,1),(43,1),(44,1),(45,1),(46,1),(47,1),(48,1),(49,1),(50,1),(51,1),(52,1),(53,1),(54,1),(55,1),(56,1),(57,1),(58,1),(59,1),(60,1),(61,1),(62,1),(63,1),(64,1),(65,1),(66,1),(67,1),(68,1),(69,1),(70,1),(71,1),(72,1),(73,1),(74,1),(75,1),(76,1),(77,1),(78,1),(79,1),(80,1),(81,1),(82,1),(83,1),(84,1),(85,1),(86,1),(87,1),(88,1),(89,1),(90,1),(91,1),(92,1),(93,1),(94,1),(95,1),(96,1),(97,1),(98,1),(99,1),(100,1),(101,1),(102,1),(103,1),(109,1),(110,1),(111,1),(112,1),(113,1),(114,1),(115,1),(116,1),(117,1),(118,1),(119,1),(120,1),(121,1),(122,1),(123,1),(124,1),(125,1),(126,1),(127,1),(128,1),(129,1),(130,1),(131,1),(132,1),(133,1),(134,1),(135,1),(136,1),(137,1),(138,1),(139,1),(140,1),(141,1),(142,1),(143,1),(144,1),(55,2),(56,2),(57,2),(58,2),(104,2),(105,2),(1,3),(2,3),(3,3),(5,3),(6,3),(7,3),(8,3),(13,3),(14,3),(15,3),(16,3),(17,3),(18,3),(19,3),(20,3),(25,3),(26,3),(27,3),(28,3),(29,3),(30,3),(31,3),(32,3),(43,3),(44,3),(45,3),(47,3),(48,3),(49,3),(50,3),(54,3),(55,3),(56,3),(57,3),(67,3),(68,3),(69,3),(71,3),(72,3),(73,3),(74,3),(79,3),(80,3),(81,3),(82,3),(83,3),(84,3),(85,3),(86,3),(91,3),(92,3),(93,3),(104,3),(105,3),(106,3),(107,3),(108,3),(145,4),(146,4),(147,4),(148,4);

--
-- Table structure for table `roles`
--

CREATE TABLE `roles` (
  `id` bigint unsigned NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
  `name` varchar(255) COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `guard_name` varchar(255) COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `created_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  `updated_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`id`),
  UNIQUE KEY `roles_name_guard_name_unique` (`name`,`guard_name`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB AUTO_INCREMENT=5 DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci;

--
-- Dumping data for table `roles`
--

INSERT INTO `roles` VALUES (1,'super_admin','web','2024-11-06 08:41:47','2024-11-06 08:41:47'),(2,'user','web','2024-11-06 08:42:40','2024-11-06 08:42:40'),(3,'Conf_admin','web','2024-11-07 03:10:44','2024-11-07 03:10:44'),(4,'Reviewer','web','2024-12-22 11:01:20','2024-12-22 11:01:20');

--
-- Table structure for table `sessions`
--

CREATE TABLE `sessions` (
  `id` varchar(255) COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `user_id` bigint unsigned DEFAULT NULL,
  `ip_address` varchar(45) COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci DEFAULT NULL,
  `user_agent` text COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci,
  `payload` longtext COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `last_activity` int NOT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`id`),
  KEY `sessions_user_id_index` (`user_id`),
  KEY `sessions_last_activity_index` (`last_activity`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci;

--
-- Dumping data for table `sessions`
--

INSERT INTO `sessions` VALUES ('0CUTpxO1eAOi0bo8iCA6y9feZ3HZx7H6RhmbJTYm',NULL,'54.88.179.33','Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/100.0.4896.75 Safari/537.36','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiQXQwY2NKZHVqME9aaXZOQ29SMVNPYVVLcXNRU3VtN0l5ZTZjczBFNCI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6Mzc6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vbG9naW4iO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737159518),('1OJxcYVOjnpOg8fJT3pvPH8YxkoC9o6cazqEAXhD',NULL,'18.97.9.175','CCBot/2.0 (https://commoncrawl.org/faq/)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiRVN4QVQzRlViZkFhbUxvTk5OVHlIYmJibENYWFlZY3BKazNNTjJhdyI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6NDA6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vcmVnaXN0ZXIiO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737110265),('27GTh502Fozgy5Fl8ir4kcztNFnrYR9Gf1cSuBmv',NULL,'45.148.10.237','Mozilla/5.0 (Linux; U; Android 2.0.1; de-de; Milestone Build/SHOLS_U2_01.14.0) AppleWebKit/530.17 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/4.0 Mobile Safari/530.17','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiM0FBZ1BIbjNvTUlSV2xaM1lHOVplTkdlZDFNc3hiR3phWFBtREo5USI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6MjU6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmciO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737220524),('3FbWmP5OvTYNm1KDnPFEIIQO187ImsLI3zS9zgtV',NULL,'18.97.9.175','CCBot/2.0 (https://commoncrawl.org/faq/)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoicUEzRFNBZ1hBWFE1U0J4MnF2YVg0VzFkc0NsQVlBQ1BRc3hOTER0UCI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6MjU6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmciO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737108243),('3qNZg2mBLpLlQcb5S0iRH5AK1u1cLVcp4uwj5RFU',NULL,'196.189.255.249','Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64; rv:134.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/134.0','YToyOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiVjk1NkpadVppU2Faa0g4RThlYkEzbnlrVEN5NUVQWWlUY25FdFlmeCI7czo2OiJfZmxhc2giO2E6Mjp7czozOiJvbGQiO2E6MDp7fXM6MzoibmV3IjthOjA6e319fQ==',1737096138),('7NbsoPDu8ZCZFj0BRKuiFY52LqN1KSgPxIdoSSW8',NULL,'54.88.179.33','Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/100.0.4896.75 Safari/537.36','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoibnVZbEZLZ2hYTHpVMFdsUEV2aGY0Y1hpZHlla3ZXOXlMajVSbDFhNSI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6MjU6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmciO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737159518),('9zHwbGhtbxjdFhrot6wklTZpfUT55QzIp2qAYOiW',NULL,'34.38.233.156','Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; rv:78.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/78.0','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiVnZBanNPUnIyTmloNWt5MlpPWVFhYWt3MWxVbHFNUmNnS1h6T1V1bCI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6NDA6Imh0dHA6Ly82Ny4yMDcuODIuODc6ODEvY29uZmVyZW5jZS9wdWJsaWMiO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737282935),('bRfr9RRnunHiJAmLMGWj5HRsnmzxIGACI7fbFPxj',NULL,'193.186.4.90','Mozilla/5.0 (Linux; Android 10; K) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/131.0.0.0 Mobile Safari/537.36','YToyOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoienZXNzFCeHoyQ29VdWY3T2JrMnlYYW1TN1lldWlURTVFbEZuR2swMCI7czo2OiJfZmxhc2giO2E6Mjp7czozOiJvbGQiO2E6MDp7fXM6MzoibmV3IjthOjA6e319fQ==',1737192771),('C4lETBqkqV7PNrMceKgIpWeeti8eCCwviZECfe2Y',NULL,'54.88.179.33','Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/100.0.4896.75 Safari/537.36','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiNVlSeXluVGJtRlNCbElJazBHeURPblJIWE5vcXFZdkdMcWFrb2VzaSI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6Mzc6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vbG9naW4iO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737159517),('cuqxVjk9GXOe6IV0SAmH60Ir5bPQ3YfZf0kMbarn',NULL,'66.249.66.37','Mozilla/5.0 (Linux; Android 6.0.1; Nexus 5X Build/MMB29P) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/132.0.6834.83 Mobile Safari/537.36 (compatible; Googlebot/2.1; +http://www.google.com/bot.html)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiQklWTEZKZWFiRmp3VDd2TFNQYVF1TEhhbzd4azJjeGVoWUhheU1iRCI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6NDA6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vcmVnaXN0ZXIiO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737285799),('eVwKfhUUhm1NSaS2VOeTTYAq7hSrnAfJuS9gOrPy',NULL,'81.209.177.145','netEstate NE Crawler (+http://www.website-datenbank.de/)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiMW41Y1ZhTGJKbFJRcklZMnBYWTNwMkFpYWdYZDZvN2xyYXhlZkJXZSI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6Mzc6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vbG9naW4iO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737149851),('fmsBSqHv4fvcWqIW8JMr1Q2mE3Lpb4tvvJeybmej',104,'196.189.182.241','Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/131.0.0.0 Safari/537.36','YTo1OntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiVUYwcXdqdzFvQ1U0ZEcySTJZZHJnZHBtTVB0cEd4Zld5MHQwTmVrVCI7czo1MDoibG9naW5fd2ViXzU5YmEzNmFkZGMyYjJmOTQwMTU4MGYwMTRjN2Y1OGVhNGUzMDk4OWQiO2k6MTA0O3M6MTc6InBhc3N3b3JkX2hhc2hfd2ViIjtzOjYwOiIkMnkkMTIkdFJkcmUxVTU5S1BtWTdjVHhDcWNFZUpTZUtHTGZQNi5YV2FnRXBKVlNzUUw4VEdwSU9BT08iO3M6NjoiX2ZsYXNoIjthOjI6e3M6Mzoib2xkIjthOjA6e31zOjM6Im5ldyI7YTowOnt9fXM6OToiX3ByZXZpb3VzIjthOjE6e3M6MzoidXJsIjtzOjU3OiJodHRwczovL3BvcnRhbC5hZmVuZXQub3JnL2FkbWluL3N1Ym1pdC1hYnN0cmFjdHMvMTA2L2VkaXQiO319',1737275796),('H7poR2gEYvb0yXuFgogKTwo1nCQrYzFBNZyAb18p',NULL,'162.142.125.211','Mozilla/5.0 (compatible; CensysInspect/1.1; +https://about.censys.io/)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiOHhLMnVWdDRyNHhWVDdsWWkySXhMVW5sVkx6Z0VQOG5xOUN1WTNaSCI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6MjU6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmciO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737183615),('hVHFn0ajov8xBAWCGodPqWgiy79oHdrNjtZTxZyW',NULL,'162.142.125.211','Mozilla/5.0 (compatible; CensysInspect/1.1; +https://about.censys.io/)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoieE9DclZHMGU2TEpYWkRlUVBWbVVwekJPZWN4U1A5aEVHb3BlYllXdCI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6Mzc6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vbG9naW4iO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737183638),('iUhumj2RzhYWzUlDdg1J4Zkazrkof5uBK7Rne3QP',NULL,'81.209.177.145','netEstate NE Crawler (+http://www.website-datenbank.de/)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiUlA5UHpUMU12R0hXWXBMN3FqSHo4dzRQZXpEOGFNQVRzSFVZakc1dyI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6Mzc6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vbG9naW4iO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737149861),('Iv81qai85FPUMux5QiPUL3tAr9M4edfJbB5Ngma2',122,'136.226.38.173','Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/131.0.0.0 Safari/537.36 Edg/131.0.0.0','YToyOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiYlFWQlc2aFJXQ2NnZ2VHSGFjNHhEbVl0cFBxOU5HbWhweWFyV3hWMSI7czo2OiJfZmxhc2giO2E6Mjp7czozOiJvbGQiO2E6MDp7fXM6MzoibmV3IjthOjA6e319fQ==',1737107428),('ji5eoa8kZf7egBnDURf9maPsUiCycOoJum6i78EU',NULL,'81.209.177.145','netEstate NE Crawler (+http://www.website-datenbank.de/)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoicnA1MmNxYWNJQ2I1QktMVDV4MWhPSDJsMWhmVVFwb3pjOWlvZnlXdiI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6NDA6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vcmVnaXN0ZXIiO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737149870),('jTLUzTkdJ6CMYXER9E1batPbMV9fy3GEYd2BaZFF',19,'41.210.154.33','Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/131.0.0.0 Safari/537.36','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',1737286976),('kcsqdXj2dQUEgS7eNDZlnE7RWBQfN2FW5pplRHwh',NULL,'66.249.66.39','Mozilla/5.0 (Linux; Android 6.0.1; Nexus 5X Build/MMB29P) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/132.0.6834.83 Mobile Safari/537.36 (compatible; Googlebot/2.1; +http://www.google.com/bot.html)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoialJaWmZpV2I0OGEyTjV0cGhpcVBlRnFDMmpIVzVrd0lNWmRmMTJQWiI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6Mzc6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vbG9naW4iO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737221902),('l1wqFKh8w3dK885EVrRB0fzlF1sRGWplgSZ8p1yJ',NULL,'66.249.66.37','Mozilla/5.0 (compatible; Googlebot/2.1; +http://www.google.com/bot.html)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiVmN6dVpHaDQ4Z1dlZVVzYlVxV2VSSWVNTXphOEZRb0JJSjFmRm9KNCI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6NDA6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vcmVnaXN0ZXIiO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737285798),('lSfUerazmOgkID4C4EPKCZXfAzEnkELgagASmkjZ',NULL,'54.88.179.33','Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/100.0.4896.75 Safari/537.36','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiOEJpdUtmODYxVm1yOFp1TklFaFpDdlN3U2JqcG9KUlBFemZzb1NZTCI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6MjU6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmciO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737159517),('MHAv0ifeDt6Zep5KHZuMiy7ct2arR8OFh032UUez',NULL,'199.45.154.120','Mozilla/5.0 (compatible; CensysInspect/1.1; +https://about.censys.io/)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiWElWR1NhRjJqeFQ5S2ZXV1MwN0ZYTEt3MDM1U3dkVnE5T1RiZVp2MiI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6MjU6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmciO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737189179),('n21Qcx4AiWEf6RzUl295h8bhkqja2Km9cxbnJGKY',NULL,'18.97.9.175','CCBot/2.0 (https://commoncrawl.org/faq/)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiOU5KSGhaN0NFSkliOFhMTWI3dUVNUHZRR29oWFczZjhvYjBZN2prUyI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6Mzc6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vbG9naW4iO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737108243),('NhOT9dSMgdgApPym9U1Y0dOpH1vHgly9Z4NPkcAC',NULL,'41.210.155.174','Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/131.0.0.0 Safari/537.36','YToyOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiZFZXU1lBZU5jZWdINUYyQm5LWElmcXN2OGJIVTNvb1RkbUlIUU1nSSI7czo2OiJfZmxhc2giO2E6Mjp7czozOiJvbGQiO2E6MDp7fXM6MzoibmV3IjthOjA6e319fQ==',1737218235),('nvIbzditQsCZnNqskmbbp0SJXGu3WcL24qxdtYnv',8,'196.189.255.249','Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64; rv:134.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/134.0','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',1737096173),('oxuar5sikAtnIGLpiRKWuBaOUB1DbZZxZ7vxe9Sk',NULL,'196.190.224.24','Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/131.0.0.0 Safari/537.36 Edg/131.0.0.0','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoicG5JejlvWk9lSGJ1MlEyeHhxaU9xSHFLdWswUE13Mkk4Z1RVMlRKNSI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6Mzc6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vbG9naW4iO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737106150),('qQmCTnuSqtqZw9XxAljtIYVRChYF02iqeLjDLAZi',NULL,'213.55.72.171','Mozilla/5.0 (Linux; Android 10; K) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/131.0.0.0 Mobile Safari/537.36','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiMXREb2k4bnJDZ05KTG4zMFVCMnNtRWRmNGNlWVdvOENybHFYV0pRNCI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6Mzc6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vbG9naW4iO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737098592),('r1zoJJDLaVGjQC3rE0G8bCeUY64Rk0Cc270xepLG',NULL,'18.97.9.175','CCBot/2.0 (https://commoncrawl.org/faq/)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiQ0R3MG5kczFJZXFXbjZSRGM0TkYzcExzdzZBdW9tMjV5NmhZeFhvbCI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6Mzc6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vbG9naW4iO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737116112),('RoSUPdjpitgZXcE2A9TkbEAi8rEgpXpdSW5XWIkX',NULL,'199.45.154.120','Mozilla/5.0 (compatible; CensysInspect/1.1; +https://about.censys.io/)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiT3V5TjF4ZlhCRHQ4WTFZTnNpbUoyY1NkeUtpaWQ2RG1ISkVmT0NMeCI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6Mzc6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vbG9naW4iO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737189196),('s5c4YrCxq59lxhUJF7MPp0HdVPhIonVLsIIRICwc',NULL,'81.209.177.145','netEstate NE Crawler (+http://www.website-datenbank.de/)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiQVFDN0Z2OUI5eHBOc0ZadXBFRGpheXNBd0pVVXgzWk1TS2tZYXhGdSI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6MjU6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmciO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737149860),('td5ghf52TMgaKEy18Wfz5ykI92zLtCueZheyH53O',NULL,'41.210.154.216','Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/131.0.0.0 Safari/537.36','YToyOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiYktZTGMyUHVRd1ZhemRHcjB4eWlYa1pxR01EYmdycnFoWXc0Z3U2eSI7czo2OiJfZmxhc2giO2E6Mjp7czozOiJvbGQiO2E6MDp7fXM6MzoibmV3IjthOjA6e319fQ==',1737126720),('uBeM7ny9WDx5WbVwFMCZvCopUJHVgVw7ny4cbJW8',NULL,'196.189.150.186','Mozilla/5.0 (Linux; Android 10; K) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/131.0.0.0 Mobile Safari/537.36','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiZmNUMHdsZzNjMUt2YWxjY2dUeU5iWWlFTWtxUnhGdDh0dDZybnJWQyI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6Mzc6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vbG9naW4iO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737271184),('UvcJ1P4EifCg6cFuMYnm5jWV7Vq6XNEc0zqyLoby',NULL,'18.97.9.175','CCBot/2.0 (https://commoncrawl.org/faq/)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiWWVuQTdkcm5JR3dxY1dGaE1nT0pzYnB4Z0haWFluZTVwQjUxTUFieiI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6NTQ6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vcGFzc3dvcmQtcmVzZXQvcmVxdWVzdCI7fXM6NjoiX2ZsYXNoIjthOjI6e3M6Mzoib2xkIjthOjA6e31zOjM6Im5ldyI7YTowOnt9fX0=',1737109945),('Ux0ZWkyQTjhBsQUqanUS6QByA0d07X0qgTOARr0g',19,'216.104.205.202','Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/131.0.0.0 Safari/537.36','YTo2OntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoidTh4TXVmOUhuSU9BMjlWN0FSdWlDbjMzMFZPS3A5Tmw2b3gyTm9iaSI7czozOiJ1cmwiO2E6MDp7fXM6OToiX3ByZXZpb3VzIjthOjE6e3M6MzoidXJsIjtzOjM5OiJodHRwczovL3BvcnRhbC5hZmVuZXQub3JnL2FkbWluL3Jldmlld3MiO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX1zOjUwOiJsb2dpbl93ZWJfNTliYTM2YWRkYzJiMmY5NDAxNTgwZjAxNGM3ZjU4ZWE0ZTMwOTg5ZCI7aToxOTtzOjE3OiJwYXNzd29yZF9oYXNoX3dlYiI7czo2MDoiJDJ5JDEyJDFsRHlOaTJqQmxTL2xZUVRCMEVPbGVmeWdRVjYuOEtMRllnLnc1dWtQM2hGOEZtejIvMm82Ijt9',1737098392),('uXlZVhq3yLV7Jd8HkFM7OfEgcHnAcRokCpqYFm64',NULL,'81.209.177.145','netEstate NE Crawler (+http://www.website-datenbank.de/)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiWXJLSUY1d1ZIWWZvaHc0OUdRcnZMT1BUVGpKaTVaaGdORklhY2pYcSI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6Mzc6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vbG9naW4iO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737149889),('UYFvKLrXwiP9KTRTcGnamESIXNx3ExKn2boKs0mS',NULL,'81.209.177.145','netEstate NE Crawler (+http://www.website-datenbank.de/)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiOU45MWxHTTZuR1d5NjRlU0hrRlJ0V21BcDZnN1V4TUdTZVkwMXp3SCI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6NTQ6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmcvYWRtaW4vcGFzc3dvcmQtcmVzZXQvcmVxdWVzdCI7fXM6NjoiX2ZsYXNoIjthOjI6e3M6Mzoib2xkIjthOjA6e31zOjM6Im5ldyI7YTowOnt9fX0=',1737149880),('vBvtmMPavDVBvED3NAFi5wvsi7hcuJ6xdynFCiei',NULL,'41.210.145.42','Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/131.0.0.0 Safari/537.36','YToyOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoicjlrRGVUZmxDM1N3djM5anFZSlVWYkVKb2p1M2JQSWNMVkdFWW1yTCI7czo2OiJfZmxhc2giO2E6Mjp7czozOiJvbGQiO2E6MDp7fXM6MzoibmV3IjthOjA6e319fQ==',1737231014),('yCd0I3Wf01luCokpkalEXV8GsCMROx9Jo7S6eMR4',25,'213.55.72.171','Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/131.0.0.0 Safari/537.36','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',1737099061),('Yer1kTbQod2CMMxL8MaDYokAuDOJ5uyPe99aa7sr',151,'196.190.112.108','Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/131.0.0.0 Safari/537.36','YTo2OntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoiRDg2b2lsWWhFRnc4ZDhGZ3lQU2ZlTm5KSnRwTE9jc3JNOFozTkJmMyI7czozOiJ1cmwiO2E6MDp7fXM6OToiX3ByZXZpb3VzIjthOjE6e3M6MzoidXJsIjtzOjMxOiJodHRwczovL3BvcnRhbC5hZmVuZXQub3JnL2FkbWluIjt9czo2OiJfZmxhc2giO2E6Mjp7czozOiJvbGQiO2E6MDp7fXM6MzoibmV3IjthOjA6e319czo1MDoibG9naW5fd2ViXzU5YmEzNmFkZGMyYjJmOTQwMTU4MGYwMTRjN2Y1OGVhNGUzMDk4OWQiO2k6MTUxO3M6MTc6InBhc3N3b3JkX2hhc2hfd2ViIjtzOjYwOiIkMnkkMTIkWGUzZ3ZkdWd2S2JCcVQ0Wk9Ec05ST0F6MGFTQVMxaTJ5SkM1SzRtQk9BcUJVeFR0dEFRdlciO30=',1737100082),('ymAjt4TlfBPnNx6oUagudddGYHjt2qqZ69xvEL5a',NULL,'81.209.177.145','netEstate NE Crawler (+http://www.website-datenbank.de/)','YTozOntzOjY6Il90b2tlbiI7czo0MDoid3FsY1R2a0hQYk5oZkJaejhBalBOVjRHcTN5Unk0a1V0c2V6czFSZiI7czo5OiJfcHJldmlvdXMiO2E6MTp7czozOiJ1cmwiO3M6MjU6Imh0dHBzOi8vcG9ydGFsLmFmZW5ldC5vcmciO31zOjY6Il9mbGFzaCI7YToyOntzOjM6Im9sZCI7YTowOnt9czozOiJuZXciO2E6MDp7fX19',1737149851);

--
-- Table structure for table `sub_themes`
--

CREATE TABLE `sub_themes` (
  `id` bigint unsigned NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
  `name` varchar(255) COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `created_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  `updated_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`id`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB AUTO_INCREMENT=26 DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci;

--
-- Dumping data for table `sub_themes`
--

INSERT INTO `sub_themes` VALUES (16,'Public Health Emergency Preparedness, Surveillance, Outbreak Investigations and Response.','2024-11-13 09:37:41','2024-11-13 09:37:41'),(17,'Vaccine Preventable Diseases','2024-11-13 09:37:50','2024-11-13 09:37:50'),(18,'HIV/AIDS, Tuberculosis and Other Opportunistic Infections','2024-11-13 09:37:57','2024-11-13 09:37:57'),(19,'Vector-Borne and Neglected Tropical Diseases (NTDs)','2024-11-13 09:38:06','2024-11-13 09:38:06'),(20,'Non-communicable Diseases (NCDs), Injuries & Mental Health','2024-11-13 09:38:13','2024-11-13 09:38:13'),(21,'Maternal, Reproductive and Child Health','2024-11-13 09:38:19','2024-11-13 09:38:19'),(22,'Public Health Laboratory Systems and Infection Prevention Control ','2024-11-13 09:38:29','2024-11-13 09:38:29'),(23,'One Health & Climate Change','2024-11-13 09:38:35','2024-11-13 09:38:35'),(24,'Public Health Systems Strengthening Initiatives','2024-11-13 09:38:41','2024-11-13 09:38:41'),(25,'Communication & Technological Innovations for Public Health','2024-11-13 09:38:48','2024-11-13 09:38:48');

--
-- Table structure for table `submit_abstracts`
--

CREATE TABLE `submit_abstracts` (
  `id` bigint unsigned NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
  `subtheme_id` int DEFAULT NULL,
  `co_authors` text COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci,
  `abstract_title` text COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci,
  `abstract_backgound` text COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci,
  `abstract_methods` text COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci,
  `abstract_results` text COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci,
  `abstract_conclusion` text COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci,
  `key_words` text COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci,
  `user_id` varchar(255) COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci DEFAULT NULL,
  `created_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  `updated_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`id`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB AUTO_INCREMENT=126 DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci;

--
-- Dumping data for table `submit_abstracts`
--



--
-- Table structure for table `titles`
--

CREATE TABLE `titles` (
  `id` bigint unsigned NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
  `name` varchar(255) COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `created_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  `updated_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`id`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB AUTO_INCREMENT=7 DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci;

--
-- Dumping data for table `titles`
--

INSERT INTO `titles` VALUES (1,'Mr.','2024-11-04 03:24:14','2024-11-04 03:27:15'),(2,'Mrs.','2024-11-04 03:24:19','2024-11-04 03:27:20'),(3,'Ms.','2024-11-04 03:24:22','2024-11-04 03:27:29'),(4,'Dr.','2024-11-04 03:24:26','2024-11-04 03:27:49'),(5,'Prof.','2024-11-04 03:24:32','2024-11-04 03:27:56');

--
-- Table structure for table `workshops`
--

CREATE TABLE `workshops` (
  `id` bigint unsigned NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
  `name` varchar(255) COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `details` text COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
  `created_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  `updated_at` timestamp NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`id`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB AUTO_INCREMENT=14 DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci;

--
-- Dumping data for table `workshops`
--

INSERT INTO `workshops` VALUES (2,'N/A','<p>Not Applicable</p>','2024-11-04 04:12:42','2024-11-04 04:12:42'),(3,'7-1-7 A for early detection & response','<p>Training on 7-1-7 Planning and Implementation for Timely Detection, Notification and Response to Outbreaks</p>','2024-11-04 04:13:37','2024-11-16 07:52:38'),(5,'FETP Quality Assurance: Accreditation/AFENET Star Rating System/REDPETT ','<p>FETP Quality Assurance: Accreditation/AFENET Star Rating System/REDPETT&nbsp;</p>','2024-11-04 04:14:07','2024-11-04 04:14:07'),(7,'Toxicological Outbreak Investigation','<ul><li><strong><em>Toxicological Outbreak Investigation</em></strong></li></ul><p><br></p>','2024-11-16 07:50:54','2024-11-16 07:50:54'),(8,'Residents Driven Project Tracking Tool (ReDPETT)','<ul><li><strong><em>Residents Driven Project Tracking Tool (ReDPETT)</em></strong></li></ul><p><br></p>','2024-11-16 07:51:58','2024-11-16 07:51:58'),(9,'Food Safety','<ul><li><strong><em>Food Safety</em></strong></li></ul><p><br></p>','2024-11-16 07:52:20','2024-11-16 07:52:20'),(10,'Mental Health Surveillance Systems','<p><strong><em>Mental Health Surveillance Systems</em></strong>&nbsp;</p>','2024-11-16 07:53:05','2024-11-16 07:53:05'),(11,'Climate Change and Health (Planetary Health)','<ul><li><strong><em>Climate Change and Health (Planetary Health)</em></strong></li></ul><p><br></p>','2024-11-16 07:53:32','2024-11-16 07:53:32'),(12,'Antimicrobial resistance (AMR)','<ul><li><strong><em>Antimicrobial resistance (AMR)</em></strong></li></ul><p><br></p>','2024-11-16 07:54:01','2024-11-16 07:54:01'),(13,'One Health','<p><strong><em>One Health</em></strong>&nbsp;</p>','2024-11-16 07:54:17','2024-11-16 07:54:17');


